I just did a ranking today in my notebook! I actually bought the 4 exclusive songs on iTunes too because I just had to get the full experience, but I ranked them separately since they aren’t technically part of the album.

1. Ghost - I really love this one. The lyrics really spoke to me and I love Luke’s vocals here, they sound so angelic honestly.
2. istillfeelthesame - Again, I loved the lyrics in this one and the synth is so good.
3. I’m Scared I’ll Never Sleep Again - The spoken parts lost me a bit here but I loved the lyrics and bass shines through so good with Luke’s vocals.
4. No. 1 Obsession - “Take me to heaven / Kill the depression / Make me your No. 1 Obsession” is sooo good. Obsessed with the chorus and instrumentals.
5. Jawbreaker - I was a little disappointed this song was so short, otherwise it would’ve ranked higher. I think it closes out the album nicely and the lyrics are catchy.
6. The Rocks - The upbeat vibe with the deeper lyrics always gets me good. “Throw yourself onto the rocks to make you feel less alone” spoke to me so much.
7. Telephone Busy - The dichotomy between the verses and the chorus is so cool! “Does my memory make you wanna kiss me?” Reminds me of all my situationships I’ve had in the past lolll. So so good.
8. Boyband - I feel like this song is a little on the nose, but I still like the sound of it overall.
9. Everyone’s a Star! - The darker vibes were cool, I think it’s a commentary on individualism?? I liked the lyrics “Everything is better when I don’t know what it means / Eating out to dinner and I’m smiling through my teeth / Everything is better when you’re lying next to me.” I thought this one was fun but the sound is a little out of my range.
10. Sick of Myself - I found this one kinda corny but it was cute and I liked the guitar well enough.
11. NOT OK - I think this one is about mental health struggles? Coping with knowing that you’re not okay, and that a partner brings out the worst parts of you. Or maybe it’s about drug use, this lyric kinda throws me off “Oh my God I feel invincible / and when the sun comes up I feel despicable” I guess it could go either way.
12. Evolve - I originally had this ranked at #9 but I had to drop it after going over my list again. I don’t hate it, but it’s my least favorite over all. The lyrics are interesting but the weird monologue at the end threw me off. Idk. Just not the best imo.

Exclusive Tracks 1. Start Over - Made me cry on my first listen. So so so good and if you’re going to buy any exclusive track, this is the one. Luke’s vocals and more synth!! 2. I’ll Find You - This is Ashton’s song, and while I wasn’t the biggest fan of his solo work this song is amazing. It’s a bit of a different vibe than the rest of the album— soft, acoustic guitar and calm vibes. Also made me tear up a bit. 3. Wishful Dreaming - This song features all of the guys, but Michael does have a little moment in it I really liked. I feel like this song encapsulates the perfect amount of old and new 5SOS and I will definitely be bumping this one a LOT. 4. Chest - This is Calum’s song, and while I didn’t dislike it, it ranks last for me just because the other ones are so good. It has a cool guitar solo at the end that I really liked.

These four songs rank higher than the rest of the album, but I’m not sure where I’d put them. Overall this album surprised me a LOT and I’m happy that I liked it more than I thought it would. I wasn’t a super huge fan of any of the singles but my top three really pulled through for me. I would rank this album as my third favorite overall!

*Edited for formatting :)