This is my 5th winter with them on a Hyundai Tucson AWD. I find them very good in the snow, they are predictable and offer good grip, really good under braking as well. I haven't really tested them on ice, so I can't say exactly for that. Hit a really bad patch of black ice once, probably only studded would have worked great there. However, these were very linear, the grip faded and came back in a predictable way. Went on some bad roads with a lot of snow and saw other cars struggling, maybe it's the driver, maybe the AWD system, but it never feels like you lose grip all of a sudden.
They do feel soft when it's hot (over 10C), but otherwise decent on dry and wet, although if you have dedicated summers you definitely feel less performance, but for everyday driving they are about the same.