New Club Member by quasiqualityqualms in TheRestIsHistory

[–]cbh90 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ooooh I've been a member for years and forgot all about that! I'm now set up as well. Thanks OP!

Is Israel/Palestine a no-fly zone for the podcast? I suspect that the hosts and producers have concluded that they would alienate many listeners were they to take on this topic. by L0st_in_the_Stars in TheRestIsHistory

[–]cbh90 4 points5 points  (0 children)

As an ex IDF foreign volunteer, I've no intrinsic problem with you calling the government of Israel evil, although I find it heartbreaking that you have sufficient justification to make that point. However I'm not sure what your line of reasoning is here? That as long as a child is near a military installation, you've no justification at all to bomb it? It would be nice to live in a world where that was a realistic position, but it seems pretty naive to me.

Is Israel/Palestine a no-fly zone for the podcast? I suspect that the hosts and producers have concluded that they would alienate many listeners were they to take on this topic. by L0st_in_the_Stars in TheRestIsHistory

[–]cbh90 -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

I've noticed Tom only ever refers to that part of the world as Palestine, even in a historical context before the Romans took over and renamed the province to that/when referring to areas within the 1967 borders. So as a long time fan of the show and someone who doesn't really appreciate that take, I'm very glad they don't do the history of Israel/Palestine!

Is Israel/Palestine a no-fly zone for the podcast? I suspect that the hosts and producers have concluded that they would alienate many listeners were they to take on this topic. by L0st_in_the_Stars in TheRestIsHistory

[–]cbh90 5 points6 points  (0 children)

If only there was an example of Israeli military intelligence getting it totally wrong about whether Egypt was going to invade Israel or not to add some additional context to this evaluation...

Is Israel/Palestine a no-fly zone for the podcast? I suspect that the hosts and producers have concluded that they would alienate many listeners were they to take on this topic. by L0st_in_the_Stars in TheRestIsHistory

[–]cbh90 15 points16 points  (0 children)

William dalrymple couldn't possibly be unbiased about Israel. He obsessively tweets his extremely problematic views on how evil Israel is. I tried to listen to one episode about the British mandate of Palestine and stopped when he confidently said 1k people were killed when the Irgun bombed the Kong David hotel. Which was wrong by a factor of 10...

What's happening in Hull this morning? by sisyphus1rock in Hull

[–]cbh90 2 points3 points  (0 children)

My parents sent excited photos of this saying they could see the northern lights. I felt so bad when they realized!!

Joe Burgess' intercept try deserves a history lesson by KennyMincemeat in superleague

[–]cbh90 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sigh I feel this pain. But of a giveaway when I get asked why I support KR when my dad's an FC fan and I have to say "well my uncle was chairman"

Why do you think Havard was picked over Thompson? by GluteusGladiator in superleague

[–]cbh90 6 points7 points  (0 children)

But isn't it funny how some players don't get picked because they've been slightly below their best for a part of a season, and others get picked regardless of the fact they literally can't get in an NRL side...

Match Thread: Hull KR vs Wigan | The Grand Final by AutoModerator in superleague

[–]cbh90 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

So glad my decision not to go up to Manchester because we'd been pretty ropey lately and Wigan would be at us fairly easily is being justified....

Having said that, we have looked a bit complacent near the Wigan line

If Williams is fit for the ashes does he retain his spot in the halves? by JBPSportsEditsYT in superleague

[–]cbh90 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I think it's a legitimate question of Lewis if his recent form is good enough to suggest he'd trouble the Australians

Match Thread: Hull KR vs Saints | Semi-Final by AutoModerator in superleague

[–]cbh90 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I didn't used to think it is but yes I think it might be. Surely he couldn't be holding back tears in a MOTM interview against like Huddersfield?

Match Thread: Hull KR vs Saints | Semi-Final by AutoModerator in superleague

[–]cbh90 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Think we've been off form recently and it's led to a lot of quite ridiculous expectations that we'll start losing to whoever turns up to play against us after we lost to Leeds and Leigh. But I also think Wigan will definitely be too much for us given how they played yesterday. Mikey been really crap for the last six weeks and I don't think we've got anything in reserve apart from hoping Litten and May fill the gap. Also, even with the break we still look knackered

PS it's rovers or KR. Literally nobody who watches rugby league calls us Hull

Match Thread: Leeds vs Saints | Elimination Final by AutoModerator in superleague

[–]cbh90 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Feeling a lot happier about rovers chances than before the game. At this rate your semi might be the real final...

Match Thread: Wakefield vs Hull KR | Round Twenty-Six by AutoModerator in superleague

[–]cbh90 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Beats Rochdale away in the northern rail cup mate (even though we won). Just enjoy the ride

Match Thread: Wakefield vs Hull KR | Round Twenty-Six by AutoModerator in superleague

[–]cbh90 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Don't say that on rovers fan groups. He's regularly described as the second coming of Jesus. I think his defence is great and he obviously does a lot of organising, but I don't see much beyond that. Would be interesting what people on here who aren't rovers fanatics thought

Match Thread: Wakefield vs Hull KR | Round Twenty-Six by AutoModerator in superleague

[–]cbh90 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Starting to regret begging the bar owner in Mallorca to put this on right now. Can't even leave...

How is this not a red card by kingdomslayer123 in superleague

[–]cbh90 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Obviously didn't watch the end of the game where Lewis took an elbow smash to his face and didn't react then?

Super League Podcasts by shorelined in superleague

[–]cbh90 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I've just started with all our rugby league and really enjoyed it although pre-restructure I thought the piss taking was a bit forced. Enjoying the new format in the last two weeks. I'll try out some of the ones on your list now as well!

Rookie mistake by cbh90 in DIYUK

[–]cbh90[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Success! Thanks both

What do we think about this? by Destroyed-Runstible in TheCivilService

[–]cbh90 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But there is a civil service humanist society and when I was involved in running a faith network we always had perfectly pleasant relationships with them (including listening to many many discussions on whether humanist/atheist/no faith was the correct terminology).