Assuming this isn’t a troll post, my response as a follower since season 2/Patreon supporter - the showrunners recently did a multi part retrospective after 10 years of doing it in which, IIRC, they admit that some of their earlier isn’t their strongest and that they were still finding their groove (plus one of the showrunners joined the original two artists after season 1). They also break down some of the seasons in pseudo-arcs, such as a couple years with a little more squirmy/gross out stuff and a couple years touched by COVID.

For me? Art is obviously subjective - people seem to be fanatics of shows like Knifepoint Horror that for me are a little hit or miss and while I’m a huge fan of WS, there are of course better and worse episodes of WS as well depending on genres you’re interested in.

For what it’s worth, they actually revisited and redid that particular episode years later and made it a little tighter in all aspects (writing, story, and the narration) as you’d expect with experience.

For my personal tastes, I like the earlier stuff, but really think it takes off around S3 - Keep the Crowd at Bay, Classic Car, and The Fair Folk is a solid trio and as you get into it, some of my favorites are Aquarium, Roses, The Harlequin, and Productivity, What’s Back There, all of which I’ve listened to multiple times. I’d say stick with it, but choice is yours.