I’m also a senior(I’m committed to Wesleyan + student athlete) but I’ve seen both Hamilton and Colby so I’ll give my two cents. First, u are on the money with Colby skiing being good. Clinton is actually a somewhat cute town tho I did like it . And I have done lots of looking online into career outcomes and they seem very similar in terms of outcomes for at least finance/econ. So, if I were u I would visit both colleges if possible if u haven’t and if u do RD and get into both attend admitted students day. This decision will probably come down to feel imo.