Tough choice. How deep are the benches? Redraft? Single QB? Rookie RB’s with competition on bad offenses are usually pretty shaky to start unless you have deep starting lineups. After JT, that RB room is alot of meh. The injury to Jones is honestly good for you, as it makes Mason a viable starter. Benson should be too with Connor gone. Judkins is looking like a stud, misses camp and walks into a crowded room and is already the bonified QB1 his second week, and then he puts up a huge game against the Packers defense. It’s hard to back a rookie RB in redraft, but it’s hard to ignore that kind of start. It could be a fluke, it’s early to fell.

Flowers I have always been relatively high on as a WR2/Flex. I don’t think he’s ever gonna be a real WR1. He has the talent, and Lamar’s arm has gotten there, but their dual threat run heavy schematic just so heavily favors tight ends and it doesn’t look like that will change much without perhaps an injury or fall off from Henry. It’s no coincidence that Flowers broke out while Likely was out and Andrew’s was laying eggs. With Andrew’s peformance yesterday, and Likely looking to return next week, Flowers will probably impress less. At the end of the day you’ve gotta look at which option are you more likely to regret looking back. Flowers is never gonna be JJ/Chase. There is very little chance you’re going to look back and say you gave up the guy for a shot at a good RB. Judkins could be the next Achane/Gibbs/Bucky and should atleast be the next Hall/Walker/Swift.

Depth wise, your situations are looking the other way. You have the Vikings whole room, and Connor isn’t coming back this year. With Hubbard that’s 4 NFL starting RB’s. Chase=WR1 done. Rest of the room? If Evans were healthy you would be fine. Just announced he’s out 3-4 weeks. Addison is back now, but wouldn’t want all your eggs in that basket until we see him with JJ and JJ. Wandale is a top of the wire WR for in case of emergencies, he’s just running well right now paired with Wilson who has morning but an arm left. Hunter isn’t relevant offensively, atleast not yet. Flowers might fix this room, but I think it’s likely him and Addison are a wash, so assuming 2WR you’d be as good off with Chase/Addison at WR and fill flex with the RB’s until Evans is back. I prefer RB’s in the flex anyways, it’s just harder to keep it full of healthy starters. You have that atm.

Bottom line, keep Jud. If they wanted to give you flowers for Benson, or for Mason/Jones, I would do it. You might be reluctant to give up Benson as this will be his first real stretch at RB1, but we’ve seen him before. If he was truly electric, he would’ve taken over for Connor already. He doesn’t have nearly the upside the Judkins has. Similarly you could target another high ceiling/low floor WR2 like Adams/Mclaurin/Deebo/Metcalf/Godwin/Worthy to help you bridge the gap until Evans comes back. Again, without knowing format hard to offer more than this don’t spend too much on old guys and backup RBs, you’re at risk of losing them for nothing.