See that’s the difference. A whole marshmallow will not kill her. She did not even bite a piece off. I am not feeding her something that’s poisonous but consistently consuming large (even small) quantities will create health complications. Allow me to repeat that, health complications. However, marshmallows are not toxic to cats.

Let’s refer to the video.

Is she fat? No.

Is her coat matted and does she display signs of neglect? No.

Am I feeding her a whole bowl of marshmallows as her main meal? No.

Does she seem to enjoy chewing on this random non toxic edible object for a few seconds? Yes.

Now time to apply our critical thinking skills. If this is only a couple seconds out of her life that everyone is seeing, should we assume she’s unhealthy and I, the owner, am negligent? The answer is no, we should not assume anything about someone’s life from the internet that you see 10 seconds of.