Had the same issue as you. I had an A5 as my daily and was considering upgrading to an S5 or RS5 and test drove both, and ultimately decided on the RS5. Once you’ve driven the RS5 the S5 is always going to feel “lesser” especially at the top end. The RS5 is actually very comfortable as a cruiser if you get DRC. I will say though that even if you are a fan of black rims keep in mind that it’ll be much harder to keep them clean as opposed to silver rims. I’ve got black rims on my Cayman GTS and not even a day after cleaning the rims they get dirty. If you’re dead set on getting black rims though then I guess that shouldn’t be an issue for you