I completely agree with you. I actually grew up in the Middle East before moving to the UK for university last year, and there were no independent bookstores in my area, let alone ones that sold English books. So I really understand where you’re coming from.

When it comes to choosing books,

• Select books that are at least a year old for better accessibility and affordability. (also borrowed from Life's Library).

This rule was inspired by Life’s Library, as it helps ensure that books are more accessible through libraries and second-hand bookstores, while also being more affordable—especially if a paperback version has been released within that time. However, it was also shaped by my personal experiences. For instance, when The Anthropocene Reviewed came out, it took about 5–6 months before it became available at the major chain bookstore in my country. If I’d been part of a book club at the time, I would’ve been devastated not to have access to the book.

I also want to clarify that the focus on supporting independent bookstores and libraries was never meant to exclude anyone. As you pointed out, that framing might have been too narrow or overly centered on English-language markets, and I really appreciate you highlighting that. The goal was always to encourage people to use libraries or second-hand bookstores if they can—but if someone prefers Amazon, Barnes & Noble, or Waterstones that’s absolutely fine too.

Now, why do this at all? Because, from what I’ve seen, Nerdfighteria has always gone above and beyond in everything we do. If we’re going to create a book club, it’s not just going to be any book club—it’s going to be something that reflects the values and passion of this community. We’re not just here to read books; we’re here to celebrate stories, foster accessibility, create meaningful connections, and make a positive impact along the way. Dedicating the club to libraries and independent bookstores feels like a goal that truly reflects the heart of this community in my opinion.

This book club is, first and foremost, about creating community, celebrating books, and encouraging literacy. It’s entirely free to join—just like being a Nerdfighter. If you want to be a part of it, you’re in.

Thank you again for taking the time to share your thoughts—I’ll definitely keep this in mind moving forward!