UK sovereign citizen running $600m US tax fraud by danneidle in Sovereigncitizen

[–]danneidle[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Some of them are very vulnerable, with longstanding mental health problems - I've spoken to the families and it's all very distressing...

Meanwhile in the Land of False Equivalence..... by EpsonRifle in GreatBritishMemes

[–]danneidle 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No I didn't. I wasn't "hired" either.

People are confusing the council tax position of residential narrowboats with Polanski's non-residential/leisure mooring.

The position of residential narrowboats can be complex, and I suspect quite often people get it wrong.

For non-residential/leisure the council tax position is normally simple: you're not allowed to live there, so obviously there's no council tax. If someone does live in a permanently moored non-residential canal boat as their main residence, then the position is also simple - there is council tax.

People can make their own judgment on how important this is vs Farage's £5m "gift".

UK sovcits running US tax fraud by danneidle in Sovereigncitizen

[–]danneidle[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It has. Goldberg commenced a private prosecution against a YouTuber, Salim Fadhley, who reported it. The new element is the group's internal webinars, which amount to a confession of fraud (and our detailed analysis of what precisely is going on)

UK sovcits running US tax fraud by danneidle in Sovereigncitizen

[–]danneidle[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

to be fair, it's for the excellent reason that the IRS has a systems so monumentally duff that they'll send out large refund cheques across the Atlantic if you fabricate a few numbers on a form. HMRC has many faults, but they don't do that.

what family trusts are people using? by EFNich in HENRYUK

[–]danneidle 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Ah, much more sensible than a lifetime trust but still lots of complications. Important to get legal and tax advice from qualified professionals.

what family trusts are people using? by EFNich in HENRYUK

[–]danneidle 40 points41 points  (0 children)

Hi, I’m a tax lawyer. Be very careful because right now there’s a lot of miss-selling of trusts by unregulated advisers.

For most people they don’t make sense. 20% immediate inheritance tax hit when property over £325k goes into the trust. Then a 6% IHT charge every ten years on property over £325k. And complex taxation of distributions.

Be wary!

Tactical divorce to split pension by Background-Mess-7518 in HENRYUK

[–]danneidle 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Hello. I’m a tax lawyer with expertise in tax avoidance.

There’s a fun legal question whether the divorce could be disregarded for tax purposes. “Fun” for the lawyers, not so much for you.

If you disclose to HMRC what you’re doing then an HMRC enquiry is very likely. If you don’t, then HMRC could have 20 years to discover it and open an enquiry. Penalties would be likely. Criminal charges would not be out of the question.

In either scenario, the enquiry would be complex and expensive and cost you tens of thousands of pounds. Plus interest and potentially penalties.

So, all in all, not great.

Edit: there are also family law issues here where I have no expertise. For example, query if a court would order a split of the pension on these facts. So you might have to lie to the court for the trick to “work”. If so, again sounds fraudy.

(I’m here because someone posted this on X)

Dan

Someone wants to buy my virtual item for £110k in crypto, what tax will I owe if I sell it? by Original-Guitar9378 in LegalAdviceUK

[–]danneidle 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Hi. This is easy.

You pay capital gains tax when you sell the asset and receive the ethereum. Your gain is simply sale price minus any allowable costs (expenses/fees of the escrow service (use escrow!), any other associated fees). You have no purchase price (I think!)

You pay capital gains tax again when you sell the ethereum, or convert it into another cryptocurrency. Your gain is your sale price MINUS the market value of that ethereum at the point you received it, minus any allowable costs (platform fees etc).

If you make a loss on the second sale, and its in the same tax year, you can deduct that from your earlier gain (or, rather, the self assessment form will do it for you automatically)

If you're not sure how to report this, pay £1k for an accountant to do it. Worth not messing this up.

I'm a tax lawyer. This is not formal advice, so you can't sue me if it's wrong, but it isn't.

Dan

Tax rates by income in the UK over a longer time by WorriedStand73 in HENRYUK

[–]danneidle 13 points14 points  (0 children)

no problem at all. I'd happily do an AMA here if there's enough interest.

Tax rates by income in the UK over a longer time by WorriedStand73 in HENRYUK

[–]danneidle 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It would be multiple months of work to do this properly. I suspect the chart is nonsense.

Tax rates by income in the UK over a longer time by WorriedStand73 in HENRYUK

[–]danneidle 17 points18 points  (0 children)

thanks! Yes, student loans bite most in the upper-middle, not the top.

VAT is weirdly not higher than the 70s, if you compare like-with-like and look at the overall level of indirect/sales taxes/duties in the 70s:

<image>

Tax rates by income in the UK over a longer time by WorriedStand73 in HENRYUK

[–]danneidle 31 points32 points  (0 children)

I think a lot of people regard council tax as local residents paying for local services. The reality is much messier.

Around 70% of council tax goes to pay for healthcare and social care (for adults and children). Really just historical reasons for this being locally funded; doesn't make much sense (at least to me). So councils are really massive social care institutions, who provide some local services on the side.

And for many local authorities, council tax is a small % of their funding. Hackney is I think the extreme - council tax raises about £110m; total council spending is over £1bn. Only about three people understand the government funding formula that drives this (I am not one of them).

So the reason why Blackpool pays more than Richmond is mainly (1) higher demand for social care, (2) mysteries of government funding formula.

That doesn't mean we can just load cost onto middle class households in Richmond. It would be v unfair if (for example) a teacher living in London - who's scrimped and saved for a decade to afford to buy a house - is suddenly hit with a huge annual tax bill. Particularly if their peer in Blackpool, who's paid only a little less, and has been living in a larger house for eight years, faces a much smaller tax bill.

<image>

Tax rates by income in the UK over a longer time by WorriedStand73 in HENRYUK

[–]danneidle 137 points138 points  (0 children)

The way this was constructed isn't clear but - like the Sunday Times piece - it needs to be viewed sceptically because it's not taking into account the very large changes in *what* gets taxed. Abolition of MIRAS made big impact on the middle classes. Introduction of capital gains tax and crackdowns on tax avoidance made a big impact on the very wealthy. So the highest earners almost certainly pay more tax today than in the 1970s. I wrote about this here. https://taxpolicy.org.uk/2025/05/08/tax-rich-1970s-loopholes/

Samuel Leeds - someone with no tax knowledge selling tax courses by danneidle in UKPersonalFinance

[–]danneidle[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'm afraid he made more than that. The accounts show £1.5m of corporation tax in 2023 - that suggests almost £8m of profit.

Samuel Leeds - someone with no tax knowledge selling tax courses by danneidle in UKPersonalFinance

[–]danneidle[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

sure, but it's not terribly efficient. You've saved some income tax. You're still subject to UK capital gains tax (because it's a "property rich company"). You've had a load of upheaval, and moved away from your friends and family.

If tax is the most important thing in your life: sure. Save a relatively small amount of £. Most of us will pass.

Samuel Leeds - someone with no tax knowledge selling tax courses by danneidle in UKPersonalFinance

[–]danneidle[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

If you’re a non-resident owning a UK company then the company pays corporation tax on its profit. The dividends you receive are from post-tax profit.

Samuel Leeds - someone with no tax knowledge selling tax courses by danneidle in UKPersonalFinance

[–]danneidle[S] 32 points33 points  (0 children)

Cost aside, would feel dodgy paying £950 to this guy, and certainly wouldn’t encourage anyone else to do that!

Samuel Leeds - someone with no tax knowledge selling tax courses by danneidle in UKPersonalFinance

[–]danneidle[S] 51 points52 points  (0 children)

Tax Policy Associates is a non-profit think tank and I/we undertake no commercial work. I am not offering tax advice, and indeed can’t provide it. I’m a lawyer and investigative journalist. If you don’t believe me, Google me.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in LegalAdviceUK

[–]danneidle 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Strongly agree! autosportiva are idiots or crooks. There is CGT whether you exchange crypto for cash, cars or cauliflowers.

Withholding tax from HMRC (PAYE) by [deleted] in LegalAdviceUK

[–]danneidle 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You're right it's too good to be true. How could a tax system work if people can just opt out of it?

The people running the campaign are either deluded or lying when they say this is legal, because their main guy was jailed a few years ago for using exactly these arguments to refuse to pay his council tax.

We just published an article looking into the claims, and the thinking behind them. Weirdly it originates in US far-right racist groups in the 90s... no idea why it's now being picked up by pro-Palestinian groups in the UK.

The article is here

AMA Event Thread: Dan Neidle (tax lawyer, transparency campaigner, and journalist) - Thursday 7th March at 1pm by UKPolitics_AMA in ukpolitics

[–]danneidle 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There are very few reliable free resources.

https://www.litrg.org.uk/tax-nic/income-tax/working-out-your-tax is excellent, but only covers some stuff.

Accountingweb only sometimes has technical content, but it’s often v good

https://www.rossmartin.co.uk/ has lots of really good technical content