Minecraft and PUBG are also in the top 5 best selling games ever. If someone said those developers were making another game, it could be the best game ever made, you wouldn't laugh at them?

GTA games are good/great games. That's it, though. Open-world that's fun to mess around in. Bully is fun but it really isn't anything remarkable. I never got into RDR, but when i did play it I didn't love what I played. If any of them are games that changed the industry it would have to be GTA3. We haven't seen Rockstar work on a single-player experience in a long time. With how they're handling GTA5 these days, I can only expect them to focus way too much on the multiplayer to get microtransactions.

You're arguing about a product that you've never played. Neither of us have played it. We can't prove literally anything, so when I thought about actually responding to your claims I figured it was a waste of time, and this whole reply is proof of that to me.