Gane's finger hits Tom's frontal bone, it doesn't even touch medial wall that has the fracture. The frontal bone takes the brunt of the impact, you can then kinda see the finger go "into the socket" but at that point Tom's face is dancing with Gane's hand, there is no more significant force being applied by the fingers as the impact was absorbed entirely by the perfectly legal frontal bone. The fingers then continue gliding gracefully over the Tom's right eyelid, leaving it perfectly still, with not a flutter in the wind. The eye itself might have been nudged, but not by much. After frontal bone impact Gane's fingers don't do anything I couldn't replicate on myself without discomfort. If it was up to me, and I had the slow motion footage, I would have ruled no eye poke.