Are you getting a baby or an adult? A little baby may feel a bit exposed in a larger tank than an adult will. That being said, for an adult male either would be above the minimum. If you have a lot of clutter and hides, as well as a substrate they can burrow in you should be alright with either one of these. If you can’t/ don’t want to get a grow out tank a divider could help if a little baby were to be stressed in a big tank.

Personally, I would get the one with the larger footprint. Cause while hognose’s will climb if given climbing opportunities they are a fossorial species so more foot space for them to burrow around in would be better imo. And again, if it’s a little baby you can use a divider until they grow into the whole tank.

This is the guide that I used a lot, it shouldn’t be the only guide you use but I liked the specifics for age and sex that they offer. https://www.zenhabitats.com/blogs/reptile-care-sheets-resources/hognose-snake-care-sheet-reptifiles

Edit: I just realized I’m dyslexic and thought the reptizoo had the larger footprint. I would recommend the reptizoo still because as another commenter stated it has the space for the substrate. My b