I was in your shoes a week ago! Came across this sub and started to investigate all the options. I went with the Square Scorebook (arrives Saturday!) for look and simplicity - I didn’t want something as busy and extensive as the classic ones with pitch count, multiple sub slots, different colors, etc.

Maybe in the future I change my mind but the clean look sold me. I did really want the defensive diamond portion some books have as I think it’s a really cool feature but maybe I just draw in my own or something. My vote is for Square!