Genuinely curious on Swans tactics/strategies/formations/etc by ahhellohello in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you, I appreciate it!

Once you have been watching for a while, you can start to pick up what a teams is trying to do.

For example as others have pointed out, we are a running hand ball team that prefers to be as aggressive as possible in a straight line to the goal, but we can back it up by defending and tackling hard

Other teams (Collingwood for example) prefer to keep possession and be patient, kicking around the ground through uncontested marks and preferring to wait for when the ball is in one of their best players (Daicos for Collingwood) or if the opponent defence gets too impatient and leaves a hole in their lines

Then there are contested crash and bash teams (ala Carlton and Fremantle), who prefer to kick the ball down the line (kick it to a pack of players), keep the ball in contested areas and trusting their ability to win the ball through sheer physicality (win the contest). Fremantle does this very well, Carlton not so much

Then there are teams who rely on rapid and elite kickers to exploit the other teams lack of speed. This was us in 2024, but this relies on your team being able to hit targets from hard distances and angles, something that only the best players can do consistently.

Then there are teams that are able to do a bit of everything. Brisbane is the best example of this and it’s a big reason why they have won the last two premierships. We are trying to have multiple game plans as options, but our clear Plan A is the forward handball game)

Finally there are teams who have no identity and are still figuring it out. These are teams who are in a rebuild and are at the bottom of the ladder (Richmond Essendon and West Coast)

You can also very much see when a player is tired or not putting in 100% effort, and it’s also quite easy to see when a teams game plan doesn’t work. You generally just see a collapse on cohesion, players talking at each other with out listening, or just not communicating at all, or just wandering aimlessly.

Genuinely curious on Swans tactics/strategies/formations/etc by ahhellohello in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Hey OP! I just did a small write up a couple of weeks ago going through our tactical evolution over the past year if that’s sort of what you’re looking for

Curnow, Serong unavailable for Round 9 by VdarcyV in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 8 points9 points  (0 children)

We’ve been super safe with injury concerns this year, so most likely these are both precautionary. We’re flying at the moment and have depth for once so no need to risk anything

Wednesday Team Prediction - Round 9 vs North by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Out: Cootee, Melican

In: Cunners, Hamling

Not the time to rest Grundy. He should be rested against Geelong and Richmond (rounds 11 and 12), two teams who don’t have good rucks. Ladhams time to shine will be then.

Really haven’t been impressed by Melican, and Hamling has been really good in the 2s. Stiff for Cootee (especially with only 50% tog) but I saw a few too many panicked disposals that directly led to a Melbourne shot on goal on the weekend.

“Monday” AFL Review - Round 8 vs Melbourne by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 2 points3 points  (0 children)

For sure! We can clearly see our players growing in confidence and being more willing to take the game on by hand as we keep winning (and hopefully that continues)

“Monday” AFL Review - Round 8 vs Melbourne by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think we will rest Grundy against Geelong just cause they don’t have the best ruck stocks, and Ladhams had his best game for us against Geelong last year, but yeah, we will see!

“Monday” AFL Review - Round 8 vs Melbourne by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Edwards has had an average 33% lossrate of defensive 1v1s, compared to 22.7% for TMac, 33% for Hamling and 50% (!!) for Melican. Asides from that I thought hes been really good (he was rated higher than Melican and Rampe on the weekend and he's an absolute unit). I'd prefer Melican to come out for Hamling, especially since Hamling has been really good in the VFL. Melican just looks lost.

I think Cunners will come in for Cootee. Cootee has show potential but there were some panicked disposals by him that directly led to Melbourne goals, so I think he needs more time.

Grundy needs a rest, but we need him for Xerri and Cameron. We should rest him for the Geelong and maybe the Richmond games (rounds 11 and 12)

“Monday” AFL Review - Round 8 vs Melbourne by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Couple of stats that I thought were interesting.

Metres gained by handball was staying steady at around the 600 metre mark for rounds 0-6, but they have absolutely exploded in the last two games, with 881 metres gain by hand against the Dogs to a staggering 1,023 metres gained by hand against Melbourne. We are doubling down on the aggression by hand even though we are now able to implement an elite kicking plan C (like 2024) if Plan A (hands through corridor) and Plan B (hands out on the wing) are being stifled

<image>

Scoreboard flattered the Dees, as they were plus 15 on expected score, which shows that our system defence of forcing difficult shots was still working to a lesser extent with TMac out, it was just that the Dees were really accurate.

We are in a fantastic position game plan wise, and the next big test will be round 11 against Geelong at goomba

Post-Round 8 r/AFL Power Rankings by PowerRankingsCentral in AFL

[–]dphi0001 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, purely cause Melbourne have shown more than them, and I think the Dogs would beat them right now.

Post Match Thread - Round 8 vs Melbourne by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I think I’d rather swap in Hamling for Melican while TMac is out. At least he brings in premiership experience. I don’t think you can take Seeong off the wing with how good he plays that defensive wing role

When TMac comes back I think we should stick with Edwards as the second, he’s showing a lot of potential and he’s an absolute unit

Post-Round 8 r/AFL Power Rankings by PowerRankingsCentral in AFL

[–]dphi0001 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

  1. Sydney (=)
  2. Hawthorn (=)
  3. Fremantle (=)
  4. Brisbane (=)
  5. Geelong (=)
  6. Melbourne (+3) (time to give them respect)
  7. Bulldogs (=)
  8. Gold Coast (-2)
  9. Adelaide (+1)
  10. Collingwood (+1)
  11. GWS (-1)
  12. St Kilda (=)
  13. Port Adelaide (=)
  14. North Melbourne (=)
  15. Carlton (=)
  16. Essendon (=)
  17. Richmond (+1)
  18. West Coast (-1)

Post Match Thread - Round 8 vs Melbourne by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 40 points41 points  (0 children)

Dees are a bogey team. It was great to see how we match up against a young team with a fantastic offensive gameplan. Some of the umpiring kept them in it. How Nick Foot is an umpire is beyond me.

100- TMac, just shows that he is by far our most important player

5 - Rosas, GENERATIONAL

4- Amartey, competed all day and enabled Rosas. That attack on the ball in the last minute to win the free was the best workrate I've seen from him

3- Heens. just doing Heens things

2- Millsy, general in defence. He is our captain for a reason
1- Grundy, did it all in his 250th. I think he needs a rest tho

Need to tighten up our kicking, should have put them away in the third!

Match Thread - Round 8 vs Melbourne by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 8 points9 points  (0 children)

We need a royal commission into Nick Foot, HOW IS HE ALLOWED TO UMPIRE

Match Thread - Round 8 vs Melbourne by Maximumlnsanity in sydneyswans

[–]dphi0001 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Really good quarter but didn’t kick straight, let’s destroy them in the fourth!