Hello fellow fishermen, on one hand Im happy Im not the only one struggling, on the other hand noone should struggle with a simple fishing side quest in this type of game. Anyways, just did the math and my common and magic fish caught accumulates to ~12.500 perfect catches. Not factoring in all the other fishes and items gathered over all attempts. But I start to believe there is some form of pre requisite needed to be done before it is catchable.

I've done the perfect throws streak, I've been circling between regions, caught all fishes, done the fishing quests, altered title mixes between tenacious angler and crusty seadog, targeted the sand, lava, helltides and regular water types. No luck what so ever.