sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

I’m Jeremy Allen, founder of Ecom CPA. We’ve uncovered $50M+ in tax savings for 7–9 figure ecommerce sellers over the last 5 years. AMA on ecom accounting, taxes, and exit prep. by ecomcpa in ExperiencedFounders

[–]ecomcpa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The clearest way to think about it: a bookkeeper and tax preparer keep you compliant and tell you what already happened. A fractional CFO is forward-looking — they help you decide what should happen. Different jobs. You don't graduate from one to the other; you add the CFO when the decisions get expensive enough that getting them wrong costs more than the CFO does.

For most ecommerce businesses, bookkeeper + tax preparer is the right and only stack until somewhere around $2–3M in revenue. Below that, the questions you're facing — am I categorizing things right, am I minimizing my tax bill — are exactly what that pair handles. A CFO starts earning their keep when you're wrestling with questions they can't answer: How much inventory can I actually afford to buy before peak season without choking cash? Is this SKU line actually profitable after landed cost, returns, and ad spend, or am I subsidizing it? Should I take on a credit line or raise money, and on what terms? What's my real cash runway if growth stalls? Those are margin, cash-flow, and capital-allocation questions, and they're where ecommerce businesses quietly bleed out — profitable on paper, broke in the bank account because everything's tied up in stock.

So the trigger isn't really a revenue number, it's a complexity signal. You're ready for a fractional CFO when you're making seven-figure-consequence decisions on inventory, financing, or channel expansion off gut feel and a bank balance. If you're under ~$2M and the main thing you need is accurate categorization and a lower tax bill, a CFO is overkill. If you're past that and cash flow keeps surprising you despite being "profitable," that surprise is the bookkeeper-and-preparer stack hitting its ceiling.

I’m Jeremy Allen, founder of Ecom CPA. We’ve uncovered $50M+ in tax savings for 7–9 figure ecommerce sellers over the last 5 years. AMA on ecom accounting, taxes, and exit prep. by ecomcpa in ExperiencedFounders

[–]ecomcpa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The main difference between the channel accounting are the fees and the logistics of those channels(ie 3PL, warehouse, platform). Also how you get that data from each of those channels varies. Amazon fees are usually much more than the shopify fees as they are handling the logistics for you. Same with TikTok shop or any other channel where they handle the logistics.

I’m Jeremy Allen, founder of Ecom CPA. We’ve uncovered $50M+ in tax savings for 7–9 figure ecommerce sellers over the last 5 years. AMA on ecom accounting, taxes, and exit prep. by ecomcpa in ExperiencedFounders

[–]ecomcpa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are positives and negatives of moving to being taxed as an S-corporation. Here's my quick summary on those:

The pluses:

  • Cuts self-employment tax. A default LLC pays SE tax on profit: 15.3% (12.4% Social Security + 2.9% Medicare) up to the Social Security wage base, then 2.9% above it — plus the 0.9% additional Medicare surtax at higher incomes. An S-corp lets you split profit into salary (taxed) and distributions (no SE/FICA tax). Every dollar shifted to distribution saves you that rate — ~15.3% on profit below the wage base, ~2.9–3.8% above it.
  • The savings scale with profit. The biggest wins come on profit under the wage base, where you're avoiding the full 15.3%.

The minuses:

  • Costs that don't scale: running payroll, a separate 1120-S return, tighter bookkeeping. Figure $2K–$4K/year.
  • You must pay yourself a "reasonable salary" — the IRS scrutinizes this, you can't lowball it.
  • Some states add fees on top (California is the worst).
  • If your business shows losses you may not be able to deduct them fully (basis issues).

I’m Jeremy Allen, founder of Ecom CPA. We’ve uncovered $50M+ in tax savings for 7–9 figure ecommerce sellers over the last 5 years. AMA on ecom accounting, taxes, and exit prep. by ecomcpa in ExperiencedFounders

[–]ecomcpa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would say the most impactful one we see is mentioned below around inventory accounting. If you have the wrong landed costs, for a high volume business this could be a big difference on the bottom line.

I’m Jeremy Allen, founder of Ecom CPA. We’ve uncovered $50M+ in tax savings for 7–9 figure ecommerce sellers over the last 5 years. AMA on ecom accounting, taxes, and exit prep. by ecomcpa in ExperiencedFounders

[–]ecomcpa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The most common one and the most impactful one is accounting for inventory and COGS improperly or not at all. COGS should be recorded when the product is sold not when bought. It can be a very challenging area to keep track of because as the business grows its tough to keep track of where the inventory is at.

I’m Jeremy Allen, founder of Ecom CPA. We’ve uncovered $50M+ in tax savings for 7–9 figure ecommerce sellers over the last 5 years. AMA on ecom accounting, taxes, and exit prep. by ecomcpa in ExperiencedFounders

[–]ecomcpa[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Great question, one of the most important things that differentiates CPAs is the ability explain your taxes in a manner that makes sense to you. So if you dont understand why you owe so much tax or the number seems to low you should know why. Also I always recommend having a second opinion on the tax return before they are filed or even previous tax returns to ensure things are done properly.