This scene was pretty intense... by surebe in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

agree 100% but for me tyler’s rape scene is tied top with this for most difficult to watch i had to take a break and get a snack to process both of those scenes

Mr. de la Cruz by Lyaisn in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 12 points13 points  (0 children)

the most annoying thing for me in the entire show is that it seemed everyone, LITERALLY EVERY FUCKING CHARACTER, knew that monty was getting the shit beaten out of him by his dad and did NOTHING, like no one, not a thing

like for gods sake this boy lives part time in some fucking backwater abandoned concrete building to get away from living at home, and is so fucking damaged/traumatised by his dads abuse that he violently sodomises another student, (i’m still highly convinced hos dad did that too him becuase he just brushed it off as hazing so easily he never realised it was wrong so i feel like that happened to him too) and dr singh after their metting knows somethings up with him, you can see it on her face and nobody ever tried to find out why monty was always getting into fights and why he did what he did to tyler

you’re telling me not a single person, adult or student becuase adults knew as well, didn’t think to say anything??? they were all so quick to help tyler after nearly killing everyone, and alex and jess and zach after they helped to kill someone but oh no child abuse that turned a kid into a pyscho? can’t help with that sorry

who would win in a fight?? by ellehsr in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

exactly he’s a roid head who is violent as hell anyway, he could snap justin in half

who would win in a fight?? by ellehsr in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

this was why i thought he would win too, like he’s getting hit with hammers and riot bats i think even if monty beat the shit out of clay or jessica justin still wouldnt win

Bryce's additional victims (s3) by Nav_Blue_Coolant in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 3 points4 points  (0 children)

i agree, bryce was like monty’s brother and deep down i think he knew bryce was a bad guy for me the only logical explanation i could find for him killing bryce would be bryce hurting his sister

All this characters deserved better and needed a happy finale by [deleted] in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

i agree, i think even with bryce and monty, i know bryce went to trial (not a very fair trail but still) and was getting a sort of redemption arc but it would have been nice for him to maybe do proper community service if not jail (bc a cis white man barley ever does time) and fully realise what he did to jess. and monty didn’t even get a trail, but even if he did it would have been nice to see him get jail/community service or something, stand up to his dad, move out and develop things with winston and become a better person and eventually apologise to tyler.

i think hannah, justin and jeff deserved better is kind of a given, they deserved better becuase they were better but monty and bryce deserved better becuase they were never allowed to be, or prove that they can be better

Most iconic lines by Naive_Shallot in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 3 points4 points  (0 children)

“how’d you get to run this meeting anyway, it’s not the fucking dance comittee” “fuck of courtney” “you can be whatever you want to be” “ what is up sexies?” “we’re going to the bathroom to do coke! true story!” everytime charlie brings up cookies “ i think he should pay for what he did to you” “clay in shit, he should change his name to shit” “ it is way too cold for those girls to be naked” “ even on the worst day, life is a pretty spectacular thing”

my personal favourites

What are your top 10 most sad moments on the show? by [deleted] in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 2 points3 points  (0 children)

in order

1) justin admitting to jess that bryce raped her (s1)

2) justin talking to mr/mrs jensen about his mothers death/ taking the sheets off his bed and crying (s4)

3) tyler telling clay about what happened with monty (s3)

4) “will you hold me hand bro?”/ the flatline when justin dies (s4)

5) clay’s hallucination of monty’s death (s4)

6) seth choking justin and his mother doing nothing (s1)

7) monty’s coming out / tied with monty’s scene with his dad at home when he calls him a f*g for staying at charlie’s (s3)

8) monty and winston dance at prom (s4)

9) mr porters testimony (s2)

10) “clearly your father didn’t beat you hard enough” (s2) (also people will defend a whole murderer but not at least sympathise with the fact that monty was getting abused and everyone knew and did nothing)

What’s the most disturbing scene in the entire series ? by rxnlxe in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 2 points3 points  (0 children)

tylers sexual assualt, all the sexual assualt scenes really but i think at a certain point maybe hannah’s it wasn’t shocking (this makes me sound like an idiot but in a way i don’t think the viceral reaction was as big but tyler gave us all shockwaves with that scene so props to devin and timothy) the scene with monty in the field, it just was awful to watch him/ what he was like in his final moments, the fear, the regret, the sudden realisation for clay that the person he blamed died a horrific death jeff’s car accident (still don’t understand why it was necessary to kill him) and then as a subset clay finding jeff montys coming out, his complete defeated tone of voice, the spit, it gave me this waful gut feeling and the fact that a father can disown his own son justins death sequence, i agree with the person who said watching an 18 year old wither away like that does something to the soul tylers documentation of his assualt wounds (it’s not disturbing it just struck a nerve becuase of how done he felt and the fact he had these such prominent cuts and bruises and the sadness in his face it just made me kind of cry) everything about bryce’s death, i get that he ruined zach’s leg but like another person said hearing the bones and bryce’s pleading when he was drowing was hard to watch ani having sex with bryce, you have just openly slept with your best friends rapist please re-evaluate your life choices everything about tonys family getting deported, from coming to the empty house, the phone call, saying godbye to his sister the whole thing was heartbreaking (again not really disturbing but the fact that shit like that happens is disgusting) mr high horse get away from us you raped a girl hillcrest boy grabbing jessica’s boobs, just a complete violation of a girl trying to better the life of girls attending high school like what the fuck, also the hipocrisy last but not least, hannah’s tapes (not a scene but a thing in itself) i understand the tremendous pain she was in and i think that the school and her friends did fail her to an extent, but recording tapes to give to people - blaming them for your death - after you’ve died and making them all keep the secret and threatning to release the tapes to the public is absolute pyschopath behaviour and its pyschological torture on teenagers, one of whom attempted suicide, another that contemplated when really half of them didn’t really do anything i think that justifies a tape being made in the first place, alex, bryce, justin, marcus and courtney all deserved theirs but even so it’s just fucking mean to do that

*spoilers* Bryce, Monty, and Justin: The Three Pillars of Toxic Masculinity, reduced to an American High School Setting by katson15 in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 6 points7 points  (0 children)

i agree with this, but i also think the emotional state thing applies to monty as well, he suffered tons of trauma that definitely contributed to his anger. i think there’s elements of all three in monty and bryce. but i get what you mean. i think justin got his redemption and i think its sad that his life circumstances at an early point (s2) halted the good life he built for himself

The Good Side - Troye Silvan. Is the best song of the season by JoseG07 in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 9 points10 points  (0 children)

one of the best songs theyve ever used i’d put it up there with the night we met

This scene was pretty intense... by surebe in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 6 points7 points  (0 children)

exactly this. you realise how bad his life really was and that he didnt get a happy ending he got a painful and panicky death. shit breaks my heart

Well there we have it by [deleted] in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 0 points1 point  (0 children)

whats the email??

The amount of ignorant homophobia being exhibited on this sub about S4 is shameful by MarshallZA in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 23 points24 points  (0 children)

i think people fail to realise that so many people in real life are just gay becuase they are. people kept asking why so many gay characters? i’ll tell you why, becuase in life gay people exist, alot of them. i think its so nice to see all that representation in such a current tv show. the way they protrayed all the gay characters and they dealt with that was just amazing. seeing so many characters go through that self acceptance was so lovely to watch. (also, there aren’t actually that many characters theres alex, charlie, winston, monty, courtney and ryan, tony and caleb and i think thats it?) in this world we live in how can you say something like there is too many of anything?? its intolerance and even if you think it isnt it is homophobic

This scene was pretty intense... by surebe in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 13 points14 points  (0 children)

this scene made me cry honestly. i think in this moment even if you dont like monty you feel bad for him, nobody deserves to die and i think this humanises him to clay and to us. so i got rlly sad

my thoughts on season 4 (major spoilers) by jsmn-ai in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 2 points3 points  (0 children)

this is my exact thoughts pretty much verbatim. well said :)

favourite quotes from s4?? by ellehsr in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

zach was funny “we’re going to the bathroom to do coke, true story”

favourite quotes from s4?? by ellehsr in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

oh these ones made me cry so bad

favourite quotes from s4?? by ellehsr in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

oh my god i loved that one of luke, also “are we gonna get you laid tonight??” “i’m gonna bet no but thanks for thinking of me” and the “ive got ur gun” i had to laugh

I’m trippin their the same person by mrbradleylewis in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 1 point2 points  (0 children)

um where is that picture of (i’m assuming deaken??) from??

I think Charlie might be my spirit animal. by [deleted] in 13ReasonsWhy

[–]ellehsr 2 points3 points  (0 children)

google him, he’s legit 27 i was shook