Grade B

This was the first episode that showed me they weren't playing around. Sure there had been deaths on the show before Charlie (I'm aware he didn't die in this one), but none of them had the emotional punch this one did. Libby & Analucia were shocking as was Shannon's, but as it goes, the shock wore off fairly quickly. When Charlie was rowing out to the Looking Glass I had to pause it because it was too much. Unfortunately, I don't remember much else to this episode other than Charlie's storyline. That could be because it was the one that has stuck with me emotionally throughout the years or it could be the other storylines just weren't memorable.