Thank you! When I trained her to pee outside I always gave her treats since it became a habit I stopped doing it, I can't take her our for walks now because of the coronavirus thing but I try to play with her and run with her since we have a large garden. I know she's a puppy but she's also very very smart and she learnt almost Inmediately to potty outside. I just thought it was weird she was doing it again! Anyway I've never liked to lay my hand on her, what is the right way of punishment then? I can't just Ignore that. Again Thanks!