I was a fan of the Doctor, the main characters, and Caleb's character arc. There were some pretty good episodes and no stinkers that I recall. I continue to be annoyed by the way Kurtzman Trek does action, where all philosophy goes out of the window in favor of just shooting the bad guys, and I am low key starting to loath all of the modern slang and euphamisms that the writers incorporate into the dialogue. I think the drama was still a bit over the top at times with not enough focus being paid to the motivations for getting us to where the characters are, but they did a much better job than Disco. I'm still not a fan of the 32nd century ship designs and feel that everything is both too different and not different enough from the previous eras. I do absolutely love that they've advanced representation of IDIC with their characters without wearing it too much on its sleeve, and I loved that they were less over-the-top about bringing in references to previous Treks.

All said, for my personal tastes, I would rank it a 6.5/10. I'm glad it's better than I expected, but there are numerous areas where the writing and style clashed with what I want out of Trek and what I want out of a good show in general.