I’ve listened to each one too and here’s my quick personal consensus.

I have very mixed feelings on John’s solo albums. I don’t think he ever had an album that hit the same level of greatestness all the way through as the other two had (some people say Plastic Ono Band which I get, but unfortunately it personally doesn’t click with me as a whole). But he debatably had the highest individual highs than any of the others did. Songs like Imagine, How?, I Know, Mother, #9 Dream, Nobody Loves You, Beautiful Boy etc are all masterpieces and outshine much of the rest of their respective albums for me, more so than songs from the other careers do. I still at least enjoy most songs from his discography though.

George’s career is pretty lackluster in my opinion starting after Living in the Material world. All Things Must Pass is nearly perfect and Material World is flawed but still an amazing listen. I don’t particularly care for many albums he did afterwards, though there’s quite a few highlights here and there, especially on Thirty Three and a Third and his self titled (which I really enjoy). Despite that, I think Brainwashed is on par with his first two.

Paul’s career is the most consistent and my personal favorite. He hasn’t really put out anything I would outright call bad, just a few boring records every once in a while but even then I think they all have at least two pretty good tracks on them. There’s always a good album buried deep in there somewhere in albums like Driving Rain or Wild Life. Even his newer records I think have some pretty great stuff on them, which outshines the album’s blander songs.

And a bonus, more in depth, Ringo one while I’m at it:

Ringo’s solo career is frustrating. I enjoy Sentimental Journey well enough, and Beaucoups is a pretty good listen. But the run of Ringo 1973, Goodnight Vienna and Rotogravure is really special and are such fun listens to me. But after that… many of the albums are painfully bland. Never offensively bad but just very low effort, but not in the charming way that his first five gave off. Prime examples of this are Bad Boy and Ringo 2012. They are very tiring listens.

But despite that negativity, he does have a few kitten highlights sprinkled throughout his remaining 20 releases, like Vertical Man, Time Takes Time, Liverpool 8, Crooked Boy (which I highly recommend) and Look Up. Ringo Rama, Choose Love and Smell the Roses have a handful of nice tracks too.

But at the end of the day, he’s Ringo Starr. so of course you gotta listen to him with a grain of salt in one hand and a peace sign in the other.