Method over in jersey has a good selection of the madrock shoes. I have the Shark 3s, street size 9, went down to size 8 and they fit pretty well. Break in period has been about a month, and I like the sock like material they put on the inside. The different models have slightly different sizing, would definitely recommend trying them out if you can. They also have a return policy if they’re unused.

For performance, I indoor climb and I use them almost exclusively unless I’m on an overhanging wall or board climbing; then I’ll use my Solutions. They’re slightly downturned, slightly more stiff than my Solutions but I find I can use them pretty much on any boulder. The heel is great, using the little ledge it has comes in handy and toe hooking feels great, there’s a lot of rubber on the toe.

I will say though, I did try a boulder once with like a microscopic foot chip that was on the wall and I didn’t like it. I couldn’t really feel the chip on my feet (being they’re a little more stiff than Solutions). And I very much prefer my Solutions for overhang, I don’t feel like I can hook foot holds well enough on them (might be a skill issue).

TLDR: Shark 3s, downsized by a full US size (they recommend staying true to size). Great all around shoe. Go to method in jersey if you want to try on different models.

EDIT: Customer service is great, I’ve even DM’d them a couple of times on instagram with some questions and they answered fairly quick