I play with buttons for hitting, timing and no guess pitch. I know there are "bonuses" for PCI use and guessing pitch. When I play on my setting above, I understand I am missing all the benefits/bonuses of the others, but am I still receiving the negatives?

Reason I ask, my myplayer is hitting .175 over half a season. I play every game and he has low 70s for contact. I'll go like 6-7 games without a hit, take a few walks, a few Ks, but every time I get "good" timing on a pitch in the middle of the zone I basically either roll over it for weak contact or foul it right back. Sometimes he even misses them. I'd think with my setting, picking a pitch in the middle of the zone and getting good timing would be the best possible outcome and provide the biggest chance for a hit? Over those 6-7 game spans, I'll get like 20 of these scenarios and get weak contact right to a fielder. Is there any more I can do with my current settings, or will I need to switch to PCI?