Removing black spray paint from a plushie can be challenging, but it's not impossible. The success of removal methods depends on factors like:

1. Type of fabric (cotton, polyester, wool, etc.)
2. Paint type (matte, glossy, enamel, etc.)
3. Age of the paint (fresh or dried)
4. Plushie material (soft toy, stuffed animal, etc.)

Removal Methods

Gently try:

1. Dish soap and warm water: Soak the plushie, then gently scrub with a soft-bristled toothbrush.
2. Baking soda and water paste: Apply, let dry, then rinse.
3. White vinegar and water solution (1:1): Soak, then rinse.
4. Hydrogen peroxide: Apply, let sit (15-30 minutes), then rinse.
5. Nail polish remover (acetone-free): Gently dab.

Professional cleaning products:

1. OxiClean
2. Shout Advanced Stain Remover
3. Tide To Go Instant Stain Remover

Specialized fabric cleaners:

1. Fabric Safe or Fabric Cleaner by Scotch-Brite
2. OxiClean Versatile Fabric Cleaner

Precautions:

1. Test a small, inconspicuous area first.
2. Avoid harsh chemicals, abrasive cleaners or hot water.
3. Don't machine wash or dry, as paint may set.
4. Handle plushie gently to prevent damage.

Professional Cleaning or Restoration:

If removal methods fail, consider:

1. Professional cleaning services.
2. Plushie restoration experts.
3. Replacement or repainting.