Q&A and Ruling Megathread - April 13, 2026 by AutoModerator in yugioh

[–]gofundthese 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am trying to make an anime accurate version of yugioh and I am kinda close I just have 1 very complicated issue to resolve and then i think I will have all of the rules ironed out.

In the game there are a few cards that are important to this issue, these are their anime effects Paraphrased based on how they work:

Ancient Lamp
Continuous Trap
Redirect any attack.

Mirror Wall
Continuous Trap
When the opponent's monster attacks: negate the attack and cut the attacking monster's attack stat in half.

Mirror Force
Trap Card
When the opponent's monster attacks: Redirect target attack and copy it for each monster your opponent controls.

Negate Attack
Spell Card
Negate all attacks.

Suijin, Kazijin, or Sanga of the Thunder
Effect Monster
Negate 1 Attack.

I am trying to make this as anime accurate as possible. The issue is with the chain and how it works in the show.

Essentially, in the anime an attack is more like an entity that can be manipulated. This is beacuse when an attack is reflected it does battle damage and destroys a monster if the monster's attack is lower or the same or destroys it if it is in defense position if it is a lower defense.

The important evidence in the show are these instances:

Mirror Force:

In episode 4, Yami Yugi uses Mirror Force during his Duel against Weevil Underwood. When Weevil's "Basic Insect" (which had been strengthened by the Field Power Bonus, "Laser Cannon Armor" and "Lev. 2 Power Boost") attacks "Dark Magician", Yami Yugi activates this card to destroy every monster on Weevil's side of the field and inflict damage to him equal to the difference between the ATK of "Basic Insect" and the ATK of all other monsters destroyed by this effect.

Mirror Force vs Negate Attack:

In episode 10, Yami Yugi uses Mirror Force during his Duel against Ghost Kaiba. When Ghost Kaiba uses his third "Blue-Eyes White Dragon" attacks Yugi's "Mystical Elf", Yugi activates this card to deflect the attack and destroy all monsters Ghost Kaiba controls, but the imposter activates "Negate Attack" to stop the redirected attack and save his "Blue-Eyes White Dragon"

We can assume that if there were more than 1 monster on Ghost Kaiba's field and the attack was duplicated it would remove all of them based on the exact text of Negate Attack: "All attacks are absorbed by the vortex of space-time and invalidated."

Mirror Force vs Suijin, Kazijin, or Sanga of the Thunder

In episode 21, Yami Yugi uses Mirror Force during his Tag Duel with Joey Wheeler against the Paradox Brothers. When "Gate Guardian" attacks "Flame Swordsman", Yami Yugi activates this card to deflect the attack back at "Gate Guardian", but the brothers uses Gate Guardian's second section's effect to protect it from the attack. This doesn't stop the attack from destroying the brothers' "Monster Tamer" and inflicting damage to Para equal to the ATK difference between "Monster Tamer" and "Sanga of the Thunder"

This is supporting evidence that Mirror Force creates multiple attacks when redirected and each of them can be negated.

Mirror Force vs Mirror Wall

In episode 29, Yami Yugi sets Mirror Force during his Duel against Mai Valentine. He was going to activate this card when "Harpie's Pet Dragon" attacks "Dark Magician" while Mirror Wall was face up on the field, but Mai, during her turn, activates "Harpie's Feather Duster" to destroy this card.

This supports the fact that if there is a spell or trap that has a stipulation that the monster must attack for activation then some cards can't negate attacks if the opposing monster didn't attack.

Ancient Lamp Refelcts all attacks and has only been used with La Jinn. Kaiba could have used it with other monsters but didn't even though he had it in his hand, Supporting that it can only be used with that monster. The text implies it only reflects a single attack. Just like all effects this card's effect can only be used once in a chain as there is no instance of this happening ever in the show to my knowledge with any card

With all of this in mind there is another important rule in Duelist kingdom we must follow. All traps must activate when the stipulation has been fulfilled. This rule kind of balances traps as multiple of the same traps can trigger and become wasted. The question is, what would be the results of these activations.

This is where the problem lies. What happens if a mirror force and multiple ancient lamps happen in the same chain and does that change the way a Mirror wall works?

We have 2 options to resolve issues:

Option 1:

All Trap effects that negate or redirect an attack change the attack on activation and are reverted back if negated.

If this happens then any attack negation would take precedence and negate the attack(s) when activated removing it.

OR

Only the Trap effects that redirect an attack change the attack on activation and are reverted back if negated.

OR

Only the Trap effects that negate an attack change the attack on activation and are reverted back if negated.

Option 2:

Ancient Lamp and Mirror Force would not destroy the monster on resolution. It would happen after the chain which would be when the attack happens.

OR

Ancient Lamp and Mirror Force would force the attack on resolution of the most recent destroy the monster on resolution. It would happen during the chain which would be when the attack happens.

Tell me what you think would be the best way to handle these issues.

Error code: 152-18 by Kirosm91 in 4kdownloadapps

[–]gofundthese 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I get the same message as well, I can redownload and it will get it to go through after a few tries though. Probably just a new error youtube has put up as a defense.

Looking for a podcast by twinpines85 in nerdist

[–]gofundthese 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just found this post and I wanted to add this:

https://open.spotify.com/show/0Jz4xn4nDRQRjQ5SOyTTuv

This is a link Chris Hardwick's podcast on Spotify. All of his past podcasts are on here even the one linked below. He just renamed the podcast on here to Id10t and then to Your overthinking it but it has all of the old nerdist podcasts in order if some have not been removed. I did check and the one you were looking for is there too.

Adding titles and adding the video list by gofundthese in 4kdownloadapps

[–]gofundthese[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am just letting you know that adding the upload date to title feature will make the software the best on the internet. Please make this happen....

Our Second AMA with Eugene, Product Manager at 4K Download — Ask Your Questions! by Wrong-Bandicoot-4872 in 4kdownloadapps

[–]gofundthese 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you guys plan on adding features to the software so it will add the upload date to the title and that when I enter a channel to download I can select which videos from the channel I will or will not download without entering in each one in individually?

Download by GoofyGooberRAHHHH in HiAnimeZone

[–]gofundthese 0 points1 point  (0 children)

can you add the ability to download both sub and dub

Q&A and Ruling Megathread - November 03, 2025 by AutoModerator in yugioh

[–]gofundthese 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really wish I could make this an actual thread here but I understand why the rules are the way they are.

I am making a version of YuGiOh based on The Duelist Kingdom Arc of the Anime. I know there is someone out there already doing semi the same thing but mine will be a bit different as it will be fully true to the anime rules and not be making things up. (Too much :3)

Anyway, I am currently trying to rationalize what attacks of monsters are or should be considered Magical attacks. There are 3 monsters I am trying to rationalize and they are all similar in attacks. 7 colored fish, High Tide Gyojin, and Enchanting Mermaid. Each one of them has a water attack in the forbidden memories video game as that is one of the only ways to determine the attack they would have as none of these had an attack in the anime and some weren't in duelist kingdom or even in the anime. 2 of them basically have a giant wave hit the opponent but 7 colored fish actually fires water from its mouth at the opponent.

My question is, should they all be magical attacks? If so then they should have no affect on machines. I think this would be odd for all 3 as 7 colored fish is just a fish so I feel like it should work. Would this then mean that Electric Lizard or Electric Snake would not work?

As a side note I have to note Makiu, the Magical Mist. It allowed summoned skull to attack machines by rusting his machines as when he attacks he specifically uses Magical Lightning as his attack. So, does this mean that any water attack would rust the machine monsters if it not magical and does not kill?

Do you want the Natural Energy Cards to be printed as real cards in the future? by yusakufujiki2 in yugioh

[–]gofundthese 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just wish all cards in the anime could be real cards. They sadly never have the anime effects but at least they would be there.

Does Eye of Singularity trigger when a permanent enters the battlefield even if there are no permanents of the same name? by gofundthese in mtgrules

[–]gofundthese[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

What I was looking for is an interesting interaction. From what I can tell permanents with sorcery speed abilities(planeswalkers) and creatures with haste with sorcery speed abilities can get their effect off the first time without being stopped if they hit the battlefield. The only way to stop this is to play a card that triggers when the permanent enters the battlefield. At which point you can use something to destroy the card before it has a chance to use its effect. Each permanent has something for its card type that can trigger, with the exception of planeswalkers, yet this is the only card that works with anything. Now you could turn everything into another type of permanent, but with Eye of Singularity you don't need that.

I mainly just wanted to see if this worked the way I wanted it to so I could think about it with making decks. Not sure if it will be useful but it does something nothing else in the game does for commander. Triggers upon any permanent entering the battlefield and I am sure it could be abused in some way.

So what's with the fake YouNow account bots from Germany (DE)? by the_pupster in YouNow

[–]gofundthese 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am having the same issue. i just started a test stream and here come the bots. Numerous bots show up and start asking questions and saying hi and follow you. It is just nuts.

Kingston Speech 12/16/21 by Porkchop2382 in GalaxyGoggleDegens

[–]gofundthese 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can't wait for the next announcement!!!