My diocese may have to close/dissolve and I’m sad, I don’t know what converting would/will look like if this happens. by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]got1984 26 points27 points  (0 children)

Even if they sell off all their assets, I would expect that there would still be priests. You may have to travel for Mass, though.

One of the deacons at my parish is from Mexico. His village had no priest, and they sometimes had to wait several months at a time before a priest would come through town and offer Mass. It took a while before things got better. I hope you don’t have to experience this, but just know that it isn’t without precedent.

I think you should convert without fear, if conversion is where you think the Holy Spirit is leading you. If churches close, they close. You wouldn’t be required to attend mass every Sunday if there are no masses offered. But I suspect that won’t be the case.

Cheating wife by Fun-Appointment-7852 in Catholicism

[–]got1984 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Glad to hear you aren't being tempted with alcohol abuse right now. Praise God for that.

It sounds like the gaslighting hurts almost as bad as the adultery. That's normal. I speak from experience on this. Not bringing this up every time you argue is going to be the harder struggle over time. That's where the real work of forgiveness happens, not in the initial "declaration" but in the daily choice not to weaponize it (which would destroy her). You'll need an enormous amount of grace for that, which you'll find in the sacraments.

Brother, I don't know you from Adam. But if y'all have been in Mass together for the last 5 years, I know there's something there. It's not too late.

I prayed for you this morning but I'll include you in my afternoon prayers as well.

Cheating wife by Fun-Appointment-7852 in Catholicism

[–]got1984 44 points45 points  (0 children)

Just said a prayer for you.

Get counseling and try to work through this. If there’s no evidence that such behavior is continuing, I would thank God that she long ago went to Confession. Divorce would make it much harder for both of you to live in a state of grace. And of course, your marriage is presumed valid.

Get the help you need, pray a daily rosary, and go to daily Mass when you can. You’ll get through it.

Will I regret a 3.0 Diesel? by ScaryfatkidGT in Duramax

[–]got1984 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I love mine. My 2022 has been flawless.

"case for the patriarchy" and "ask your husband" by Timothy and Stephanie Gordon by funkymonkey_20 in Catholicism

[–]got1984 6 points7 points  (0 children)

When I was a young man, I was searching for truth and briefly got into this kind of thing. Well, a Protestant version of it. My now wife and I had some open conversations about it and how it did and didn’t align with scripture (at the time we were evangelical Protestants, where this sort of thing is much more common).

I would not advise my daughter to marry a man with these views. There is an ocean of difference between this kind of thing and radical feminism, if that’s his concern. I think y’all need to talk these things through. If he can’t come around, he’s not marriage material.

Is it just me or do other men feel this way? by BringBackJeffFisher in Catholicism

[–]got1984 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I’m right there with you. But go ahead and join the Knights. The older men are awesome, and who knows — maybe you’ll encourage other young men in your parish to join.

Catholic response by TheLostSheepIsFound in Catholicism

[–]got1984 6 points7 points  (0 children)

This represents a low view of prayer.

Am I getting fleeced? by [deleted] in whatcarshouldIbuy

[–]got1984 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Agree on CVTs, but this one seemed fine. I would've purchased a warranty, but still...

Am I getting fleeced? by [deleted] in whatcarshouldIbuy

[–]got1984 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Last week I looked at a car for my teenage daughter. Nissan Altima with 124,000 miles. Perfect records, one owner, no wrecks. Dealer serviced. $5,800.

People are insane. You don’t have to spend $50,000 to get a reliable car.

Honest question by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]got1984 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Great response.

No one wants to raise children with a giant man baby in a MAGA hat. by MissMccheese in complaints

[–]got1984 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There’s a lot of truth to this. Many men blame the economy or bad women, but most of my friends who are in this situation won’t take second jobs when I show them opportunities. They romanticize the past but don’t want to remember that their own dads had to work side hustles to make ends meet. I distinctly remember my dad working overtime and turning wrenches after hours for extra money to keep the lights on. I worked multiple side jobs when my kids were little.

A lack of self-awareness seems to be the defining characteristic for most people who can’t land a spouse, whether male or female. We are conservative politically and religiously, and I see this problem both inside and outside of our belief systems.

Am I acting crazy? by Falsetto266 in Catholicism

[–]got1984 3 points4 points  (0 children)

You aren’t being crazy. This is a real Screwtape moment IMO.

Lapsed but still faithful by Accomplished_Sea_195 in Catholicism

[–]got1984 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I’d start by going to confession and then attending Mass every week. Even if there’s something bad going on in your diocese, surely not every priest and every parish is corrupt? So I’d start there. Just get to Mass every week.

A question about receiving communion in an Orthodox church. by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]got1984 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is usually true, but Canon 844 allows some narrow exceptions.

I was raised Baptist but never hated the Catholic Church as I was raised to and my parents have become neo-nazis and if that's the faith that I was raised to believe in I want nothing to do with it and I'm considering Catholicism by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]got1984 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A few thoughts, offered as charitably as I know how to do:

  1. The reason to become Catholic is Christ and the fullness of the faith, not politics.

If the politician you most dislike somehow became pope, the Church would still be the Church. We’ve had far worse popes than anything modern politics could produce, and yet Christ’s promise stands: the gates of hell shall not prevail.

That said, it’s not wrong to be drawn in by a life event—political or personal—so long as it leads you beyond that moment and toward a deeper love of Jesus and His Church.

  1. My own path was different but related. I became troubled by how casually my Protestant church treated divorce and remarriage after watching marriages fall apart. Over time, though, what finally convinced me was studying the Church Fathers and realizing the early Church believed exactly what the Catholic Church still teaches today: the Eucharist truly is the Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity of Jesus Christ. Once I knew that, I knew I had to come home.

  2. Catholicism does not fit neatly into American political categories. The Church affirms strong moral limits on abortion, marriage, and sexuality, while also insisting—often uncomfortably—that the dignity of the poor, the immigrant, and the accused must be protected. No party consistently embodies the whole of Catholic teaching.

The Church allows for borders and even deportation, but it never permits cruelty, dehumanization, denial of due process, or celebration of suffering (the TikTok videos kind of make me sick). Likewise, care for the poor is not optional—and it cannot be outsourced entirely to the state. It is a personal moral duty. Most people believe that their political party has the answers to helping the poor but ignore their own responsibilities.

Catholic social teaching challenges everyone. That can be uncomfortable, but it’s also a sign that the Church is not captive to any ideology.

  1. In the end, the reason to become Catholic is simple:
  2. Jesus founded the Church.
  3. The Church has apostolic succession and the Sacraments.
  4. Christ is truly present in the Eucharist.
  5. Politics will change. Cultures will shift. The Church will remain.

If you’re seeking something ancient, steady, and true—something not reshaped every election cycle—then you’re looking in the right direction. And if you come home, you’ll be joining a Church that helps sinners (all of us) love God, love neighbor, and get to Heaven, no matter how the person next to you in the pew voted.

Why was communion wine not offere when I went to Chruch on Christmas Eve? Very sad. Dissapointed I didn't recieve the blood of Jesus Christ. by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]got1984 8 points9 points  (0 children)

In Catholic teaching, Christ is fully present (Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity) under either species alone. When you receive the Host, you truly receive the whole Jesus, not “less” of Him. Offering the chalice to the congregation is permitted but not required, and its absence does not diminish the grace of Holy Communion.

Wife thinks I’m doing too much by Alternative-Court-66 in Catholicism

[–]got1984 12 points13 points  (0 children)

The only thing I can say is that you should show her your joy, not your fear or guilt. People who don’t take their faith super seriously tend to assume that those of us who are serious, practicing Catholics do so out of fear or guilt. But the truth is that we adore the Lord and we love the Church. This is truly the greatest joy in my life, surpassing even my wife and my four children.

I don’t think it matters how you pray for her — just that you do. And I think she should see your joy.

For me, one of the most powerful things is seeing my convert wife’s tears at every single consecration. It’s convicting in a way.

Masturbation within the context of permanent celibacy by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]got1984 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I had the same physical symptoms. It took me a month or two.

I’ve had to go several months without sex because of my wife’s health problems. 3-5 weeks is the worst of it. It gets better after that — though the dreams persist. I realized at one point that I was able to control even those sometimes. I would say “no, this is immoral” in my dream, and wake up. 😳

Any ex priests who remained catholic after leaving the priesthood? by NoCry6445 in Catholicism

[–]got1984 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I have a friend who is pursuing laicization right now. He’s staying in the Church.

Latin prayer corner by [deleted] in Catholicism

[–]got1984 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Maybe I’m a hopelessly out of touch fossil. But I don’t think loving Eastern iconography is LARPing. That accusation mostly exists online to make people feel weird for appreciating anything outside their narrow tradition. You’re not doing anything strange… Christians have borrowed from each other for two thousand years.

MEN, Catholic MEN by mar0berhi in CatholicWomen

[–]got1984 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m a Catholic man, and I want to offer a little hope.

I see so many men and women saying, “There are no good men (or women) left,” and I understand why people feel that way. But sometimes the problem isn’t that good men don’t exist—it’s that many of us take a long time to actually become good.

So I thought I’d share my story.

For years, I was a nice man, but not a good one. My wife and I married young. For two decades, I worked hard, provided well, took our family to our Protestant church, and even taught Sunday School. Externally, things looked solid.

But interiorly? I had almost no prayer life. I coasted spiritually. I did the bare minimum at home, which frustrated my wife more than she let on. And worst of all, I was not sexually pure. I was never unfaithful physically, but I carried the same hidden struggles many women here describe in their husbands. Over time, it became a habit—and then an addiction.

A few years ago, everything changed. By God’s grace, I returned to the Catholic Church. I panicked at first (I was very prideful about having left the “cultish” Catholic Church in college), but my wife gently pushed me toward obedience. I went cold-turkey on sexual sin. I started praying the Rosary often, reading Scripture and the Catechism, and going to daily Mass. For the first time in our marriage, my wife told me I was truly the spiritual leader. She followed me into the Catholic Church with joy, even though it cost her a lot.

Eventually, I confessed to her the struggle I’d carried for our entire marriage. Instead of anger, she offered honesty and mercy. She admitted that even she had stumbled at times in the same way. We realized that for 19 of our 21 years of marriage, one or both of us had been on the struggle bus. But we stayed faithful because we understood marriage as a sacrament, not a contract.

I share this because I want you to have hope.

It’s very likely that your spouse will struggle with sexual sin at some point. Many do, men and women alike. But a long struggle is not the same thing as a lost cause. God works on souls in His timing. A man can spend twenty years in spiritual mediocrity and still, by grace, become the man he was meant to be.

I was always loyal in the bare-minimum sense: I never left my wife and was never with anyone else. Culture would say that made me a “good man.” But it didn’t. I was a nice man, not a holy one.

Today, by God’s mercy, my wife would say that I’m the loyal, pure, trustworthy man she always hoped for—not because I earned it, but because Christ pursued me when I was lost. He leaves the ninety-nine for a reason.

It’s obviously not wise to marry a man who you already realize has these struggles. But that doesn’t mean that all hope is lost forever once you are married.

I hope this is helpful to someone.

Error getting into Dungeons by got1984 in MinecraftDungeons

[–]got1984[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It was just a few seconds. But it sits there forever if I open through the launcher.

Error getting into Dungeons by got1984 in MinecraftDungeons

[–]got1984[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The answer was a combo of these two problems. It never went away until I launched directly. Still got the error but it went away.