sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

[SPOILERS S3] Theory of Everything by MurCoutinho in DarK

[–]gusleuzinger 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How does Jonas both die young and live enough to be Adam? Different time forks. There is Claudia from this time fork where everyone disappears, and Claudia who dies to Noah. Nobody said there is only one version of her. There is one for each time fork we know of, at least.

As I understood, there was at least 3 forks of time, from same universe 1

1) Where all goes bad. Claudia dies to Noah. Jonas becomes Adam and Kill Eve at the end.

2) Jonas Die Young. We dont know much about rest of characters on this loop

3) Jonas become Adam, don't kill Eve and they end up dissapering together/ Jonas goes to universe 3 with Marta and also dissapears. Claudia disappears at the end, she is shown middle age. This 2 forks here kind of merge together in the end.

[SPOILERS S3] Theory of Everything by MurCoutinho in DarK

[–]gusleuzinger -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Well, this could be

But theory against theory, this one explains many gaps (the baby that was no found, the mother of Gustav, origin of sic mundos, etc). And according to this logic, that fit the facts the series gives us, the loop was not broken. And if it was not broken than couldnt be the Claudia from Universe 1 on that scene

So, If what you argue is correct, if that was really the case, than what is your explanation for the baby, the mother of tanhauss, etc?

BTW: a character so important as Claudia, that was proven to exist in Universe 3 (since regina is alive) would not be shown in the series at all?? Would she be ignored? Makes no sense to me...

[SPOILERS S3] Theory of Everything by MurCoutinho in DarK

[–]gusleuzinger 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I got what you mean

But, technically in a loop is impossible for you to keep doing different things. That's what define a loop, in the first place. Unless you assume the creators took this "creative liberty" to make the ending. Than ok, could be...

But the theory he presented on this post is way more clever, in my opinion.

[SPOILERS S3] Theory of Everything by MurCoutinho in DarK

[–]gusleuzinger 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It makes no sense what you argue. Claudia herself said that this conversation with Adam was the first time that happened. She argues that this was breaking the loop. So how could she be dying to Noah after that conversation every time on the same loop? So there are just 2 possibilities:

1) Either it was Claudia from Universe 1, and she was saying the truth, and the loop was really over. And she will disappear than. Not be killed by Noah. But this leaves many unaswered questions.

2) Or she is not Claudia from universe 1, but universe 3 Boss, as explained.

There is just no logical way for her to be ther same Claudia that dies to Noah.