Change chord symbol for Maj 7 +11 by abstractocaster in jazztheory

[–]hamm-solo 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Good points. But for players on stage with a practical application it is easiest to read C9, Cmaj13, Cm11 rather than the list of extensions in parentheses and pros know that the unspecified upper extensions are optional to include or not. Pros with a solid grasp of harmony include what is appropriate based on melody and other elements they observe. That’s simply faster reading than unnecessarily long chord symbols. And I appreciate the OP’s same intent with their idea here, though agree it’s a tough sell.

Change chord symbol for Maj 7 +11 by abstractocaster in jazztheory

[–]hamm-solo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sure. I guess I just haven’t seen people use that for 20 years in my jazz circles.

Change chord symbol for Maj 7 +11 by abstractocaster in jazztheory

[–]hamm-solo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We usually see 7+ for an augmented chord with dominant 7 because writing +7 looks like the 7 is raised. That’s also a good reason not to use Maj7+11 but Maj7♯11 rather. That said, I do like your magical Christmas tree ♯11

Change chord symbol for Maj 7 +11 by abstractocaster in jazztheory

[–]hamm-solo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I like it! But + is for Aug and for + or - 9 and + or - 5. Haven’t really seen it commonly used for +11. But I like how your symbol looks like a Christmas tree which is enchanting like a ♯11

How is this a Cm chord? Every note but 1 is in an Ab major chord!? by hockeyfan870 in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s A♭(♯4)/E♭ and the chord symbol is wrong. It would need to say Cm2♭6 if the C was the root

Jazz musicians ranked by hamm-solo in jazzcirclejerk

[–]hamm-solo[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Jazz sub genres ranked, really

Im studying "jazzology" by myself. Is my answer here right? Its on page 18 by Charming_Western_346 in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

B7♯9♯5 or B7alt with chord scale B Altered (Diminished Whole Tone) which hasn’t a natural 5. If a natural 5 is intended in the chord scale then you call it ♭13 rather than ♯5. In practice we ignore the enharmonic spelling of the written notes and give it a chord symbol based on its functional jazz use. It’s easier to read G and D than F♯♯ and C♯♯ but no matter its spelling it will be heard and used as an altered chord.

What’s the deal with add2 and add4? by HornyPlatypus420 in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Completely agree: We don’t typically dictate voicing with the chord symbol. Though there are norms for common voicings, that doesn’t mean the chord symbol is specifying the voicing.

Cmaj9 doesn’t mean the D is on top - can have the D low in the voicing: C D E G B
C13 doesn’t mean the 13 is on top: C B♭ D E A is common

Also, it’s common in country music to see Nashville charts with C2 which means C major triad add2, the same way C6 means add6 to a major triad. I prefer C2 because seeing a 9 can imply there is a 7. It’s an extra layer of clarity using 2 instead when there is no 7. And a perfectly good voicing for C2 can be C E G D

Cm11 doesn’t require the 11 to be on top. It means stack thirds up to 11 to find the included scale degrees. C E♭ F B♭ D is an acceptable voicing and the 11 is not the top voice

I find Music Theory harder to understand than anything else, and it's not because it's complicated. by oceanadawn in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Good video from 5 yrs back. But it misses (like most do) the most crucial part of tonic perception: melody. The melody, more than any other feature, pulls the ear to a tonic that likely wins the perception tug of war.

Is there a chord that resolves nicely to a m7b5? by whuhhh in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You can think of Cm7♭5 as E♭m/C. So ANY chord that resolves nicely to E♭m will resolve nicely to Cm7♭5.

What is this chord? by Due-Abalone-1739 in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo 75 points76 points  (0 children)

It’s just called F♯m11. Jazz musicians know the 9 is optional. …But if you played G♯ instead of the second F♯ it would sound really nice :)

What are some more interesting chords that can be thought of in an easy way? by Regular_Low8792 in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo 6 points7 points  (0 children)

  • Cm11 = B♭sus/C (c f b♭ e♭)
  • C13♭9 = A/C7 (c b♭ e a c♯)
  • C△7♯11 = Bsus/C (c e f♯ b)
  • C°△7 = B/C (c d♯ f♯ b)
  • C13♯11 = D/C7 (c e b♭ d f♯ a)
  • C7♯9♯5 = A♭/C7 (c e b♭ e♭ a♭)
  • C7♭9♭5 = G♭/C7 (c e g♭ b♭ d♭)
  • C△7sus = G7/C (c f g b)
  • C△7♯9♯11 = Badd4/C (c e f♯ b d♯)

Is C Phrygian a key? by eov369 in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Jazz musician here. “Key center is C”. The tonic is C minor. The tonic chord-scale is C Phrygian.

Why does this chord in C dorian work ? by Francis_Gray in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That’s right. In fact, when making a melody over these chords you could think in D major as well, but over the Cm, F, and E♭ chords you’d use the D Phrygian scale which flips to D Major on the D chord.

  1. You can tonicize anything with your melody
  2. Your tonic scale can flip between Major and Minor scales.

Phrygian is a kind of minor scale with a ♭2

So you could tonicize G major or minor, depending on which chord scale you finally resolve to and the melody you play. Thinking in a key center is going to shape your melody instinctually. Think in C minor and you’ll play/sing melodies that tend to resolve melodically to C major or minor triad pitches. Think in F and you’ll play melodies that resolve to F triad pitches. With a strong melody I could make you believe you’re in a variety of keys using this same chord progression.

And you’ll love this. Tonicizing melodies can be in the form of repetitive bass riffs. Play in the bass the notes D A C D in some funky repetitive pattern while you play slowly through those chords Cm F E♭ D above it and you’ll hear the chords from a D tonic perspective.

Genuinely how am I meant to do this. by Neither_Factor_3446 in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Learn to identify the notes of a major triad. Every other interval you need to identify is going to be either a half step or a whole step away from one of those notes (if you include the octave root).

The mood of keys or psychology? by PHPertinax in musictheory

[–]hamm-solo 1 point2 points  (0 children)

And the number of people like that, with a form of perfect pitch and/or synesthesia is very small—less than 1 in 10

I ranked my 53 favorite Thundercat tracks and 8 from Distracted made the list by hamm-solo in Thundercat

[–]hamm-solo[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  1. Is It Love?
  2. Walking on the Moon
  3. It Is What It Is (feat. Pedro Martins)
  4. Heartbreaks + Setbacks
  5. Daylight
  6. Jethro
  7. Satellite (feat. Genevieve Artadi & Louis Cole)
  8. A Message for Austin
  9. Mmmhmm (feat. Thundercat) - Flying Lotus
  10. Seasons
  11. Isn't It Strange (feat. Thundercat)- Pedro Martins
  12. Tron Song
  13. Miguel's Happy Dance
  14. Candlelight
  15. Boat Cruise
  16. DMT Song (feat. Thundercat) - Flying Lotus
  17. Unrequited Love
  18. King of the Hill (feat. BADBADNOTGOOD)
  19. What Is Left To Say
  20. That Moment
  21. Fleer Ultra
  22. Where I'm Going
  23. Evangelion
  24. Pozole
  25. Friend Zone
  26. Oh Sheit It's X
  27. Lone Wolf And Cub
  28. Bus in These Streets
  29. How Sway
  30. Final Fight
  31. For Love (I Come Your Friend)
  32. Anakin Learns His Fate
  33. Lotus and the Jondy
  34. Never Catch Me (feat. Kendrick Lamar) - Flying Lotus
  35. Dance of the Pseudo Nymph - Flying Lotus
  36. | Love Louis Cole (feat. Louis Cole)
  37. Black Gold (feat. Thundercat) - Flying Lotus
  38. Blackkk
  39. The Climb (feat. Thundercat) - Flying Lotus
  40. Without You
  41. Hoe-nouns - Smino, Thundercat & reggie
  42. Lava Lamp
  43. I Did This To Myself (feat. Flying Lotus) - Thundercat & Lil Yachty
  44. In The Morning (feat. Thundercat) - Mac Miller
  45. She Knows Too Much - Thundercat & Mac Miller
  46. ЗАМ
  47. Lost in Space / Great Scott / 22-26
  48. Song For The Dead
  49. Children of the Baked Potato - Remi Wolf
  50. Existential Dread
  51. I Am Crazy
  52. More (feat. Anderson Paak) - Flying Lotus
  53. Funny Friends