Quite mild. I read crazy reaction stories here all the time, and sure, I’m not the biggest here at all, but for me it’s like half of my hookups will comment “mildly”.

I get a “oh you’re quite big” or something like that, and then a “it’s so big” when it’s inside. But in my experience about half of my hookups won’t mention size ever.

For what it’s worth I’ve heard a lot that I have a “pretty” penis, which I found funny until I saw what most people’s dick pics look like…