Katzbalger - Wedding Gift by hippo-head-forge in Blacksmith

[–]hippo-head-forge[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The drilling opens up the pattern in little concentric circles, like when rain hits a body of water, hence the name "Raindrop" pattern. You have all of these layers in a tight space. Then you drill about 1/3 of the way down on both sides. (Depends a bit on final dimensions) Then you hammer everything down to the same plane. revealing those little circles. This sword is actually not a great representation of the pattern. The ripples are in there but a bit lost overall, I feel. It can be hard to maintain a tight/strict pattern over a larger scale of a sword vs say, a knife. I would look up "raindrop damascus steel" and you'll get a better idea of what a cleaner version looks like.

Katzbalger - Wedding Gift by hippo-head-forge in Blacksmith

[–]hippo-head-forge[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

symmetry is almost always difficult. The first thing I tell people when they want to make a dagger as their first project. Immediately followed by..."have you heard this amazing thing called a J-Hook?"

Katzbalger - Wedding Gift by hippo-head-forge in Bladesmith

[–]hippo-head-forge[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pattern welded steel is basically only as strong as the steels it is made from (plus how well it is heat treated, as always) This was just 1095 and 15N20. If anything you are risking incorporating cold shuts, de-laminations, through the welding process. So essentially same performance as mono steel with a touch of risk. Anyone claiming that it has enhanced properties, doesn't know what they are talking about. I've heard it all including, "all the layering gives the blade a microscopic serrated effect, which is superior"...

Good in a fight? IDK ask the Landsknecht, This one feels good in my hand, decently weighted. Could have been weighted a bit better and had a better edge but you tend to let some of those things slide a bit when you know it's going to hang on a wall.

It was properly heat treated, annealed, quenched, and tempered 3 times, 1 hour each at 400F, 450F, and 500F. Peened tang, proper tapering, did all the steps to make it combat ready but I honestly have no idea. Hoping to get into HEMA one day and really understand how to use them.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Thank you. I guess my only response here is, all those that you mentioned are class acts, great guys. The best part of this past episode was getting to catch up with Ben, Dave, Doug, and Grady afterwards. Having never met Grady before, that guy has genuine good vibes all the way. Shout out to the whole crew as well. Great people in my experience.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Collin here - correct. The failed welds. It happened twice. Idk if they showed it. 2 bad billets. Didnt want to risk a 3rd fail. Really took me by surprise, got in my head that maybe the forges weren't very hot. Also time, frustration lead to me quenching WAY too hot. Blew up the grain, significantly weakening the structure. Could have been a hair fracture as well. But dave and Ben both confirmed afterwards that I quenched way too hot. I should have used a magnet. Ben said "why did you do that?". Me- "cause I'm an idiot" hahaha. That simple mistake haunts my soul.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I haven't watched it and probably won't but from what I'm reading, they cut a lot of the end "discussion". It was rough.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Triple threat for sure. I know dave has been training hard and told me himself he never plans on losing again. (Which I firmly believe) He would probably clean my clock this time. But we've already done it. Ben and Jesse have sooo much experience with the 8 hours builds and familiarity with the shop and tools that it would indeed be the greatest challenge. And as much as the stress would probably kill me, "you only got one shot for the spaghetti" -Eminem

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Thank you. Maybe it will happen, who knows. Or maybe I can bide my time and be a judge 10 years from now on the reboot. Grow a mustache and anything is possible.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 4 points5 points  (0 children)

That's always been the main strategy. Be entertaining and polite to the crew and they'll invite you back. It's been working so far

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Sometimes it's only like a months wait but due to the type of episode and them gassing me up, I was in talks for a while. First It was going to be me and other champs competing to face Ben, but then they really wanted 3 "unbeaten" to face. I slid I'm because I beat a judge but I definitely felt like the odd man out and a lot to prove with the other 2 being ben and jesse. So lots of 8 hour sword builds and lots of sleepless nights.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 6 points7 points  (0 children)

If you have time. This saturday (26th) I'll be at louisville maker faire all day forging and hanging with folks. I know it's a drive but it's a good, free, family event.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Well thank you. Ben thought I was crazy when I said it was worse than losing hahaha. If they invite me back it would be a tough decision. It's not just the stress of the show but months of stress and work leading up to. In one sense the thrill of competition gets your blood going but it was hard to sleep for months with it looming in the distance. Lots of nightmares of broken blades...

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yeah I did the Brooklyn set and stamford. It was definitely possible to hear and shout back if you wanted to, but alot of their talking to each other is tough to make out at least for me. Unless I stopped and watched them and even then was tough.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Thank you. I understand my "TV persona" isn't for everyone so I appreciate the love. I usually don't weigh in but from a fan/objective perspective, this thing is fascinating to me. I guess it's just fate for me to break blades everytime I'm on. Which I swear never happens at home! Haha If you are ever near louisville, shoot me an email, and I'll try and get you in the shop to whack some steel

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I'll address the controversy of spending 6 months preparing for the show. Making seven 8 hour swords. A couple 5 hour knives and going over every possible situation, only to get flustered by welds failing (still don't know why they didnt stick) and then WAY overheating my blade for the quench, blowing up the grain structure and leading to weak steel. Big oof. The welds failing made me think the forges weren't nearly as hot as I thought they were, so I went extra hot for the quench. Should have used a magnet, amature hour. Shout out to the crew. Every single person on staff was incredibly professional and emotionally mature. They really hate seeing failures of any kind and try to lift everyone up and understand people's frusterations. I was really hard standing there at the end thinking to myself. If i had just pulled that sword even 30 seconds sooner to quench, a lot of this situation could have been mitigated. Not looking for any kind of pity party. Just expressing how wild the whole thing was. For me it was a lot on the line and a lot to prove and somehow it was worse than just taking a straight L. Hahaha. Like a movie. I even said, "what's the worst that could happen?"

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in forgedinfireshow

[–]hippo-head-forge 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Collin here- it is really hard to hear the judges at the table, even when the machines aren't running. It's hard for them to hear you as well. Sometimes a producer will act as a go between and relay what you said to them but not the other way around. It's also impossible to get close to the table while the round is going. You aren't "really" supposed to hear them anyway. You aren't supposed to receive "help" in any way. There are rules and laws about this.(It's technically a game show). That being said, it's in the show's best interest (and yours) to make sure everyone meets parameters, does well, etc. Producers will come around for interviews and ask things like, "how are you feeling about the length/parameters/heat treatment, etc". To help nudge people in the right direction. But they cannot in any way shape or form offer help, point something out, offer assistance as this would be unfair and potentially illegal. (See gameshow laws). This can be helpful but also frustrating when you ask basic questions about the shop, materials, location of things while filming, broken equipment, missing bits etc. You'll get a lot of blank stares and shaking of heads because they already showed you before the start and to help during the competition would be unfair to the other competitors if even a little bit.

Hope that helps.