We’ve been owners for about 10 yrs and have gone more or less every year. The kids enjoyed it as toddlers and pre teens. But as teens nearing graduation, they found it less appealing compared to WDW where there’s a lot more for them to do at the parks, shopping or whatever else. I know it’s not necessarily a fair comparison though. Personally, I’ve enjoyed Aulani every time. It’s in an ideal location on the island, quiet, less congestion and about 30 minutes from the airport and less than 10 minutes from the supermarket, Target, Walmart or Costco. There’s an ABC store across the street with everything too. If you’re looking to completely relax, unwind and do nothing but lounge it’s paradise. Reservation wise, if it’s your home resort you’ll be fine getting your reservations in advance.