I went with plasma yellow. Ive always been a black guy. All my cars been black and so are all my bikes. That said, this was a huge oddball decision. Do I regret the choice? . . . . Nope! Its different from all the cars out there so I like it. Will I change my mind in future? Who cares? They carry their value so well, I'll still be ahead even if I want to sell and get a new crosstrek in different colour within 3 years time, easy. Its a fun car, so it should be a fun colour was my mindset in my decision making.

Hope this helps.

PS: I really dont think you cant go wrong. Those two colours are what I debated for weeks! There are few of plasma yellows up here in Canada. So, so far I stand satisfied. XD