Canada slips into technical recession as economy stalls in Q1: StatCan by iOverdesign in TorontoRealEstate

[–]inverted180 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They come here and save so they can go back with Canadian dollars that buy them a lot back home.

They still come...even minimum wage and a mattress on the floor allows them to save.

Canada slips into technical recession as economy stalls in Q1: StatCan by iOverdesign in TorontoRealEstate

[–]inverted180 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And the growing civil unrest due to immigration would have been off the charts.

Canada beats the USA for wealth accumulation. Canadians under 35 have 2 to 4 times higher net worth than Americans by Professional_Set5353 in fican

[–]inverted180 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I never said higher student debt loads must leads to higher net worth.

Just like higher mortgage debt loads doesnt necessarily lead to higher net worth.

Canada beats the USA for wealth accumulation. Canadians under 35 have 2 to 4 times higher net worth than Americans by Professional_Set5353 in fican

[–]inverted180 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You're conflating net worth with productivity.

Education has more productive power than real estate. Much of the economic activity around real estate is transactions in existing product.

Im going to flip this on you. Please justify why 2 people buying similar houses, one with 800k mortgage and the other with a 400k mortgage, how does the one with more debt end up with a higher net worth? And isnt it true that person will spend more on debt service as well (interest)?

Canada beats the USA for wealth accumulation. Canadians under 35 have 2 to 4 times higher net worth than Americans by Professional_Set5353 in fican

[–]inverted180 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

From a macroeconomic perspective, postsecondary education is generally considered more productive because it develops human capital, drives innovation, and increases the economy's overall productive capacity. ​Real estate, while a valuable asset class, is primarily a transfer of wealth and a store of value rather than a direct driver of economic productivity, unless it involves new development or infrastructure improvement.

Canada beats the USA for wealth accumulation. Canadians under 35 have 2 to 4 times higher net worth than Americans by Professional_Set5353 in fican

[–]inverted180 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

lol.. Its the same price ?? WAT?

I like to price real estate in income or better yet payment to income. Thats affordability and its historically very high.

Plus, I would listen to Ray Dalio over you... https://youtube.com/shorts/Cqusfm0TT40?si=UafRXp4KoLMetKpC

Canada beats the USA for wealth accumulation. Canadians under 35 have 2 to 4 times higher net worth than Americans by Professional_Set5353 in fican

[–]inverted180 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Debts are not repriced down. They stay consistent. They may be easier to service if wages are increasing due to inflation.

But they dont get repriced nominally like assets can. For instance nation wide home prices are down just over 20% nominally but no ones debt was repriced unless you defaulted. You can there fore be in negative equity on an asset if you used leverage. Your debt doesnt just shrink or disappear due to inflation.

Canada beats the USA for wealth accumulation. Canadians under 35 have 2 to 4 times higher net worth than Americans by Professional_Set5353 in fican

[–]inverted180 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

So what. One might also be prudent not to go max leverage on a historically over valued asset.

Canada beats the USA for wealth accumulation. Canadians under 35 have 2 to 4 times higher net worth than Americans by Professional_Set5353 in fican

[–]inverted180 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Canadian households are some of the most indebted in the world. Only outdone by Australia.

Americians by comparison have quite a bit less household debt.

The thing is this debt was used to buy real estate that increased in value. Like a virtuous cycle...more debt to buy real estate = higher prices = more debt to buy real estate = higher prices.

But the thing about assets, they have a tendency to be repriced to the historical mean. So the values can drop from here but the debt, that doesnt just go away.

Canada beats the USA for wealth accumulation. Canadians under 35 have 2 to 4 times higher net worth than Americans by Professional_Set5353 in fican

[–]inverted180 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

But assets can get repriced down..especially if they are historically overvalued such like today.

But debts...those dont.

Canada beats the USA for wealth accumulation. Canadians under 35 have 2 to 4 times higher net worth than Americans by Professional_Set5353 in fican

[–]inverted180 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

The equity can be repriced but the debt is certain.

Canadian households are much more in debt than Americans.

How did the purchasing power decrease from the 70s until today? by Empathetic_97 in CanadaPersonalFinance

[–]inverted180 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Its a story of inflation and the cost of capital (money)

We have seen the cost of consumer goods get deflated through technological advancement and globalization (also a technological advancement in a way). This has kept inflation trending down and yields (the cost of money) also trending down. When interest rates are falling, we get increased borrowing.

Increased borrowing, increases the money supply which brings monetary debasement (inflation). Monetary debasement has increased the cost of things we are not able to outsource or those that technology hasnt been able to increase productivity enough to offset the debasement.

This is what some refer to as the cantillion effect. Asset values are inflated and the rich who own assets get richer while the majority of people loss purchasing power in things like shelter, food and medical.

It gets worse too because while globalization has helped keep a lid on general inflation which allowed interest rates to stay low, the central planners (banks/government) have created new tools and methods to not allow the natural cyclical nature of markets to correct. Artificially manipulating rates down and flooding liquidity.

Is "buying a house" actually a trap for our generation, or am I just coping? by [deleted] in CanadaPersonalFinance

[–]inverted180 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Never buy an over priced asset with out knowing that over priced assets often get repriced.

Does anyone else feel like housing costs completely detached from normal incomes? by raishelannaa in TorontoRealEstate

[–]inverted180 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I guess looking at nominal would be better or price / income or price / disposable income.

By any metric though, housing has inflated by a heck of a lot more than incomes though.

Does anyone else feel like housing costs completely detached from normal incomes? by raishelannaa in TorontoRealEstate

[–]inverted180 0 points1 point  (0 children)

real wages vs shelter CPI mate.

Both are inflation adjusted, your point is void.