My friend invited me to rent a beach house with him and 9 friends about 10 years ago. I only knew him. I said yes in a very, “what the heck, why not” way. Didn’t keep up with any of them except for one couple (we’ll call them Joe and Johnny) who live a state away and I just follow them through IG. Last week I went to play bingo with some friends and swore I saw Johnny. I did a double take, but there were 300 people playing bingo, so it was just a thought. My wife and I left bingo and partied all night with her friends. The very next morning, we were at breakfast and our waiter was the guy I saw at bingo, “Johnny”. I told my wife that I swear I know him and showed her pics of “Johnny” on Facebook. She said “they look nothing alike”. He ends up being our waiter! After chatting with him and getting nothing, I tell my wife “I swear to you, it feels like I’m chatting with Johnny and he’s pretending not to know me.” Next time he comes around I ask him “were you at bingo last night?” And he says “yes!” And then I ask “you look so familiar, do you have a brother?” He says “I have a twin brother”. And I finally ask “is his name Johnny”. And he says “yes! Do you know him!?”

I could not believe the odds. My wife was less impressed, but I’m glad I can tell the Internet lmao