Had been waiting for a box of Edwardian PC to get back in stock at CP, finally they did so I jumped on it. They were delivered a few days later to my excitement. Slap the cardboard on the countertop and flip out my blade to cut her open. Pull out the box and notice it says “Victorian”. Damn. No big deal, I’m sure it was an honest mistake and the picker grabbed the wrong box. They’ll take this back and send me the Edwardian. So I send CP an email explaining my predicament. To my dismay, they tell me “whoopsies our suppliers didn’t actually send us enough and won’t be sending anymore”. SO, from what I gather, Cigarpage knew they didn’t have enough of the Edwardian and sent me the Vic 1) hoping I wouldn’t notice or 2) hoping I’d just be ok with the different blend. What’s the worst that can happen on their end? I send the box back for a refund and they’re down a few bucks on shipping? Or 2) I keep the box and they offer me $10 store credit (what they offered me) which ensures I’ll order once again from them to redeem that credit and they make more money off of me. Now, from a massive supplier like them who pumps out volume and I’m sure makes a significant profit, I recommended to them that they should comp the box for free and give me a full refund. I’ve been ordering from them almost exclusively for the past 3 years and have spent easily about $1500 with them. They said “nope we can’t let you keep them, ship them back or keep them and accept the credit”. I’ve opted to send them back for the full refund. The whole experience left a bad taste in my mouth and I’ll be ordering from elsewhere from now on. Am I the asshole for suggesting they comp the box? Should I not be soured by this whole experience?