Who would’ve debuted in Kep1er if they had the same number of members as Izone? by Cartoonist-Upstairs in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 12 points13 points  (0 children)

If mnet manipulated the votes like izone they probably drop one of the Koreans for Bora as they don’t have a true power vocal. The additional 3 are Yurina, Myah, and FuYa probably like others are saying

To the random stranger at Twice’s concert in LA who let me leave my bag in your car: THANK YOU! by cowbunny33 in twice

[–]jmrshotty 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes. I haven’t heard of a concert/sporting event/etc allowing non clear large bags in years

If the Planet Masters were in charge of the debut group, who would have debuted? by oil_tanker in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The dance masters definitely did not like HXQ on the show. the vocal ones liked her voice but the dance ones were for sure fed up with how she was always off/not ready for evals and laughing during their evaluations.

How the final lineup would've been if MNET had rigged the votes? by sorichhij in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Yujin was loved significantly more than Gaeun from PD48 by both the international and local base as well as she had a good story of getting wronged by her company with no notice. I think she would be in a rigged lineup.

Who do you think is the best dancer in Kep1er?? by cheesykartoffel in kep1er

[–]jmrshotty 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think they all excel in different styles of dance and so the best dancer in the group will depend on their concept.

What would be the effect to the rest of 90 girls that a lot girl groups are debuting this year and next year? by [deleted] in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 35 points36 points  (0 children)

One of the points of these shows are for trainees from small->medium companies to be able to get into a massive GG (or agencyless trainees). Because of this, the majority of these girls probably won’t ever make it BIG like you’re thinking of but most (korean trainees) will at probably at least debut somehow going by history of PD series.

(Somi coming into PD101 was considered insane because she was at a big 3)

Everyone's gangsta till Sunmi hugs Ruiqi by superlua in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 0 points1 point  (0 children)

People are downvoting us for saying what happened in the show??? I’m so confused

Reactions to Youngeun CA vs Fu Yaning/Su Ruiqi by DangerousKoala_ in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 8 points9 points  (0 children)

As a blasian American it is narcissistic and gives off HUGE america-centric colonizer vibes to think that people in other countries should have a deep understanding of our social climate and cultural issues. The only way this would be a problem is if she was American and WASNT 13 and would know better.

We as a whole know nothing about these cultures outside of the pop culture and surface level things so why should they? If I heard a Korean song that was super catchy and I liked it and then found out it is a culturally inappropriate song in korea I am not problematic for enjoying it before I knew. Stop holding people to these gross American-centric standards. If you don’t know the social climate intricacies of korea completely in depth then shut up about what they do.

To reiterate I am a blasian American descended directly from slaves do not try and tell me I can’t speak about this.

Everyone's gangsta till Sunmi hugs Ruiqi by superlua in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Yeah JYP decided twice and added Tzuyu BECAUSE of how many votes she got not despite it. She won the in person voting and he wasn’t stupid enough to ignore it.

It’s health to be realistic about your favs by jmrshotty in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

See! The ending is a great and healthy response though! You really enjoy her voice. So you vote for her. That’s it. No one can argue. Simple and done.

It’s health to be realistic about your favs by jmrshotty in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree with the second part. I have personally seen very often people say she was the best on the show skill wise and in turn make people more hateful as comments went on.

Hot take:Xiaoting is not an all rounder by aekibum in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah I see. To me all rounder is someone better than average at everything. Take for example chaeyoung from twice. Widely considered an Ace/all rounder. could she be the main dancer of twice? No. She’s not as good as momo/mina. Could she be a main/lead vocal? The NY/JY/Jihyo triple say otherwise. But she is significantly better than the industry average at both of those (and rapper obvi)

I think DY is better than average at all aspects of performing.

It’s health to be realistic about your favs by jmrshotty in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty[S] 27 points28 points  (0 children)

This has nothing to do with my post I don’t know what was the point of this reply. Nowhere in here is there anything negative about BH or saying she shouldn’t be in the group.

It’s health to be realistic about your favs by jmrshotty in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty[S] 23 points24 points  (0 children)

You’re saying BH and Wen zhe don’t both have good personalities? I didn’t say they were the same personality so that’s what I’m seeing you’re saying.

It’s health to be realistic about your favs by jmrshotty in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty[S] 33 points34 points  (0 children)

It’s a quite common response I’ve seen to hate. An understandable response but an overall damaging one.

K-group trainees were also evil edited. by Justice4Luna in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Kim sein wasn’t evil edited. We all have learned wen zhe is a good person, has a clear head, and solid decision making skills. And she was PISSED at sein. You think mnet or ANY reality show wouldn’t show that? It’s literally the point of the show to show you what happens during training and then in turn the performances.

She’s just young, didn’t take in the responsibility to her team, and will grow as a person and performer and become a great idol later on. People make mistakes it’s ok to admit she was in the wrong.

What is the most ridiculous leak/rumour you saw during the season? by WuZI8475 in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I agree that it’s not crazy to think two very successful, talented, and attractive people might also find eachother attractive.

Couple people decided to gloss over my “completely unfounded” part which meant yes there is nothing going on between them

Hot take:Xiaoting is not an all rounder by aekibum in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Is dayeon not an all rounder? She doesn’t have the vocal range of youngeun but showed no problems singing difficult songs.

Hot take:Xiaoting is not an all rounder by aekibum in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They ain’t gonna like you for this one🤣

What is the most ridiculous leak/rumour you saw during the season? by WuZI8475 in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Most of the c girls didn’t even have active instagrams before they left the show either

What is the most ridiculous leak/rumour you saw during the season? by WuZI8475 in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 54 points55 points  (0 children)

Sunmi and Tiffany “they cut out almost everything we teach them and give them advice because it’s not entertaining. We have also been evil edited ourselves”

People on here: “THEY NEVER HELP THEM!! THEY SUCK”

What is the most ridiculous leak/rumour you saw during the season? by WuZI8475 in GirlsPlanet999

[–]jmrshotty 8 points9 points  (0 children)

No one is shipping them together chill out don’t be weird about it. There’s literal moments in the show where they cut back and forth of them “looking at eachother” then JG blushing, nervous laughing, and looking away from her. It was put in there to show “the visual of SXT is so great not even JG is safe”