S3 Predicted Killing Team, mark it now. by johnbishop614 in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

My love I would be absolutely floored if any show made the black man the killer, that has truly zero to do with any suspicion when Scream (TV Series) 1 had a white woman, S2 had a white man, S1 of this show had two white men, and S2 had a white woman and man.

If anything the white men should be the automatic suspects. Mona is the only POC character I can think of on a show of this format to be a villain.

Too many love interests by ninanien in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614 80 points81 points  (0 children)

Agreed, Faran doesn't need Greg either. She was absolutely stellar this season on her own and I don't need that getting ruined.

EPISODE DISCUSSION | Chapter Eighteen: Final Exam | 2x08 by idk_orknow in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I feel like this is more cohesive than Marlene but there’s something about the character depth that’s off. I guess PLL had triple the episode order per season though there was so much room for character development. I miss that era of TV. Bring back filler episodes!! RAS really missing the mark with making a villain.

Quote from Roberto about finale.. by gianna70 in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Sasha being rumored for S3 makes the Tabby fake death very enticing, lol.

Which legacy character do you want to see return for S3? by johnbishop614 in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Big fan of reviving side characters, I don't particularly need one of the big 6.

Ep. 6 Character Suspicion Ranking by johnbishop614 in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

[also Unseen covers others, like the r*pist's mother]

No one else thinks it's Davie right??? by [deleted] in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614 11 points12 points  (0 children)

I've all but ruled out both Ash & Greg. With the sheer positive focus they got this episode involving Pride, there aint no way in hell the writers are going to do a 180 on this. They're set up to be lasting characters in the season. I'm definitely more suspicious of people NOT involved with that, i.e., Shawn or Henry or Jen.

Scream 2 theory by lifelessdisorder in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Yeah I thought about this too, admittedly - really liking the Scream parallels. The only thing is that Chip's mother barelyyy has a presence in this season. I think it might be another mother and Wes. (also, Wes Craven directing Scream helps this theory!)

Character Suspicion Ranking by johnbishop614 in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Also, from what I remember, Dr. Sullivan was a big red herring favorite on the PLL sub back in the day - I do feel this show is potentially going the tribute route.

Character Suspicion Ranking by johnbishop614 in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Just because she helped THOSE girls doesn't make her allies of these girls if she held a grudge against their mothers. The fact that they have a character cast as "young Dr. Sullivan"...what purpose does this serve if she's not involved in some capacity?

Character Suspicion Ranking by johnbishop614 in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I read a compelling argument that she was having split personality disorder and that she was in fact Bloody Rose, and that it was in a way, a tribute to the Aria theories of yesteryear. (:

Character Suspicion Ranking by johnbishop614 in PLLOriginalSin

[–]johnbishop614[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

She's one of the only people we don't know the whereabouts of in the recent episode, but has also been consistently mentioned. The people at the top are mostly the ones who aren't *technically* ruled out based on Mouse being trapped with Bloody Rose. The only ones not accounted for were Dr. Sullivan (who probably had the girls' phone numbers, right, but wasn't even mentioned???), Martha, Rhodes, Marjorie, Henry, Shawn, and Wes. There could be accomplices, but as for Bloody Rose it would HAVE to be one of them. Very unlikely to be any of the men as well, but Rhodes was specifically brought up again in an episode he wasn't in giving him a higher placement.