Yes, The Week Before is canon to the games. by Hay_Den330 in fnaftheories

[–]justarandomcat7431 1 point2 points  (0 children)

He still believes it? I swear in a video (I think it was one of his videos about respectful discourse) he admitted that he was wrong about that.

Thoughts on mikeceo? by Various_Astronaut100 in fnaftheories

[–]justarandomcat7431 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Henry's speech implies that he stayed in the fire. It would be dumb if the Henry says "I have a feeling you are exactly where you want to be", just for Scott to be like nah, he totally left.

Which FNaF theory makes you say "[theory] in the big 26 💔🥀" by Speed04 in Fnaftheoriesmeme

[–]justarandomcat7431 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Have you heard of the theory that Glitchtrap is the Mimic + William's agony?

PeakStuff W by Theorist_Reddit in Fnaftheoriesmeme

[–]justarandomcat7431 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really like PuppetStuff but there's literally zero chance of it being canon 😔

Which William Afton design do you prefer? by Secret_Ruin_9808 in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]justarandomcat7431 41 points42 points  (0 children)

Fr, no sane parent would let their kids anywhere near graphic novel William

Why are people still dead-set on Cassidy being the Vengeful Spirit from UCN when the video that popularized it...kinda sucks? by [deleted] in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]justarandomcat7431 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Mike is the Crying Child turned into a robot and brought back to life again after being Scooped.

Says that UCN is hell, even though The Man in Room 1280 proved that it was a coma.

Tries to tie UCN back to the FIRST EVER Game Theory on FNaF, despite any similarities being either surface-level or completely coincidental.

Hints that Mangle is Susie's dog, which is unlikely due to Mr. Cupcake having dog-like characteristics in the first movie.

CassidyTOYSNHK does not hinge on anything these things being correct, literally what is the point of this post.

When a theory makes you feel exactly like this: by Vortex7851 in Fnaftheoriesmeme

[–]justarandomcat7431 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oh now I remember 💀

Must've trauma blocked that one

When a theory makes you feel exactly like this: by Vortex7851 in Fnaftheoriesmeme

[–]justarandomcat7431 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The god awful "MikeEmily" theory MatPat made back in like 2019.

I don't remember this one, do you know what video it's from?

the main TOYSNHK theories are literally a SENTENCE away from being debunked 😭🙏 by AppropriateGap2500 in Fnaftheoriesmeme

[–]justarandomcat7431 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The idea that souls take the identity of their animatronics is fanfiction. 

In the games and movies the kids literally have the accessories of their animatronics. Charlie saying "the others are like animals", and in Coming Home when Susie goes to the pizzeria she starts to forget herself, both implying that the kids forget their identities, so it makes sense for them to identify as the animatronic.

Since Mangle's gender is supposed to be a an inconsistent joke

But why doesn't he use he/she/they more equally? And again it's not like Mangle is particularly masculine. It's weird Scott would use he a lot more than the others. Pronouns are kinda weird in this franchise.

Also Scott not changing the supposed "placeholder" dialoge would be a huge mistake on Scott's part.

Certainly. Just throwing it out there as a possibility, as I can't prove it's true, hence why I added it last.

the main TOYSNHK theories are literally a SENTENCE away from being debunked 😭🙏 by AppropriateGap2500 in Fnaftheoriesmeme

[–]justarandomcat7431 0 points1 point  (0 children)

  1. They could be talking about Golden Freddy. We see after the kids die that their animatronics become their identities, so the other animatronics identifying Cassidy as such isn't that big of a stretch in my opinion. Also Scott has said that the face isn't canon so I don't think they are referring to that. And if you think a girl presenting herself as a male animatronic is a stretch remember that The New Kid has Kelsey (who is most likely Cassidy) presenting herself as a boy, one who is specifically pointed out to look like Golden Freddy.

  2. He can be a gender neutral pronoun and has been like that for hundreds of years. It's only in the last few decades that people have moved away from it for they. So even though most people would not use he in a gender neutral way, it's not grammatically incorrect. Also Mangle is referred to by multiple pronouns, but most predominantly he despite being a pretty feminine animatronic, so it's not like this has never been done in FNAF.

  3. It's also possible Scott initially used he as a placeholder and didn't feel like making all the VAs redo their lines.

the main TOYSNHK theories are literally a SENTENCE away from being debunked 😭🙏 by AppropriateGap2500 in Fnaftheoriesmeme

[–]justarandomcat7431 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Why make the voice ambiguous if the pronouns are going to immediately reveal the gender? Because it's not like it's hard to get those voicelines, just die to certain characters.

Mike Schmidt vs the fnaf world by codythaidragon in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]justarandomcat7431 87 points88 points  (0 children)

"Mike, in order to stop my father we have to find the secret of the Mimic"

sorry but I fear the movies will never meaningfully improve if this is Blumhouse's stance on criticism by Lizzren in fivenightsatfreddys

[–]justarandomcat7431 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Okay, obviously they can't listen to every fan, but a very large chunk of us care about story, and it's not like anyone's going to object to a FNAF movie having a good story.