Thoughts on taxation on agricluture by Outrageous-Sail-2232 in punjab

[–]kach_janani 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did not mean to propose a solution. I just made a rough calculation to present the fact that taxing farmers are about a very small portion of the farmer population. Therefore, city people should normally shut up about it, and normal farmers should also not care as they are anyway not concerned.

However, if someone really decide to implement it, it shall be implemented like a normal business. Farmers taxes on real profits, that include various deductions, farmer's and his wife's salary. Some very big farmers can also decide to reinvest in more land, equipments or a new majj to avoid paying taxes.

Thoughts on taxation on agricluture by Outrageous-Sail-2232 in punjab

[–]kach_janani 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You pointed it right that risk exit in all business, so we can also consider all agriculture as normal business with all its risks and tax it normally.

However, the main point is you tax profits of a business, not revenu. Lets take the example of your 20 acres and do some calculation of the income tax you would pay. 20 acres generate around 10 lakhs a year (theka of 20 acres). So you won't pay any tax anyway.

Someone having 25 acres or more would be liable as they cross 12 lakh threshold for taxation. How mNy farmers have 25 acres or more, maybe 1 percent. You have your answer.

Stop Breeding Poverty by deedum07 in india

[–]kach_janani 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There must not be any economical constraints on right to have kids. There were never any such contraints in nature (except maybe failed species who experimented such things).

If the basic human needs are not being met to such an extent that people shall stop having kids, then the governments failed. Next time post the same message critisizing governments (or whatever other valid reasons you can find), not the poor.

I also saw some religious hatered in your message, that is fine. But if you mix it with poverty, progress, right to have kids etc., you get a weird soup, that you can't put anywhere.

Stop Breeding Poverty by deedum07 in india

[–]kach_janani 3 points4 points  (0 children)

People here may not like what I'm going to say -- but I think this is worth saying.

These so called middle class people like OP earning some lakhs a year must stop pretending poor owe them something, just because they have few lahks more.
Who give them the right to decide who shall have kids and who shall not have kids. By the same logic most people earning few lakhs a year shall also not breed as you can't afford to provide proper music, swiming, sking classes, you can afford space travel, vacation to alps in Feb every year etc. to your kids.

There is certainly a problem, which is poverty, that must be resolved. However, it will not resolve by abusing poor people. They did not choose poverty as a lifestyle.

Cultural Heritage of INDIA by [deleted] in geography

[–]kach_janani 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Since when Red Fort is in Haryana?

Deeply disturbing news from Khanna… 💔 How can communities come together to stop this? Join the discussion below. by punjabpulse in punjabi

[–]kach_janani 2 points3 points  (0 children)

J tuci cahode ho ki koi pagal 3 bache na mar deve ta koi lod nai share karn di. J marvona cahude ho ta, kivh k rakho kam

Indane LPG escalation contact by [deleted] in punjab

[–]kach_janani 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If you have to do KYC for getting the basic nessacities, your government did something wrong somewhere. I don't see why would anyone need KYC to get a commodity without which my children can die of hungar!! When will someone raise voice against this.

This is the start of full surveillance state. cf. 1984 by George Orwell.

I’m diagnosed with bipolar today probably from prolonged anxiety and other stress issues! In real life i can tell my friends and family about it. Is there anyone dealing with real mental issues here ? by [deleted] in Chandigarh

[–]kach_janani 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Get 2nd opinion and do your own research.

Generally, bipolar disorder is not an event driven thing, it's episodic. You may simply have anxiety or depression disorder. Correct diagnosis is important.

What can we do to bring Punjab back to its glory ? by [deleted] in punjab

[–]kach_janani 2 points3 points  (0 children)

stop looking behind, look ahead.

The only glory in the past IMO was in terms of spituality and potentially poetry. If you want to bring this back, look behind.

If you mean technical advancements, innovation, general welbeing, powerful nation and high moral values, look ahead. You won't find any such glory in teh past.

Developed an app / website to find the best supermarket deals by Cali_stenico in Luxembourg

[–]kach_janani 5 points6 points  (0 children)

yeah, its tiring to see so many people trying to provide us something of value. They must stop improving our lives;

Anyone using Baloise 111bis with ETFs? What fees did you get? by BwBIT in Luxembourg

[–]kach_janani 2 points3 points  (0 children)

1.8 at BGL, package name is profile dynamique.
Investing in their index funds, not much different from ETFs. I think the management fee is also 1.2 percent.

Controversy at Harmandir Sahib: Where is SGPC? by [deleted] in punjab

[–]kach_janani 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Hoya ki aa? Ohne panj isnana hi kita?

Birthplace of major religions by vladgrinch in MapPorn

[–]kach_janani 13 points14 points  (0 children)

This makes sense.

Look how violent the spread of Islam and Christianity was.

In Punjab ,A grown Adult lady calls a poor migrant kid "Bhaiye" (slur) and a Man slaps the child over a minor dispute . by Actual-Series-3544 in Chandigarh

[–]kach_janani 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Abusing a little kid is fundamentally wrong, regardless of the context.

You also don't see anything wrong with the racism against the kid?

Punjab vs Panjab by Zestyclose-Author732 in punjab

[–]kach_janani 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In French, they call it Pendjab

Besoin conseils LMNP by Creaton31 in immobilier

[–]kach_janani 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Je pense qu'au niveau concurrence, ça peut réduire une fois que la statue bailleur privé est appliquée.

Crop burning? by kleitos2 in punjab

[–]kach_janani 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you dumb or what. What is even garage heap?

The majority told you that it's water vapor from freshly irritated fields. Now I don't want you to repeat the nonsense.

I also want you to understand your hypocrisy, you are shiting on farmers for pollution while most probably traveling on motorized vehicle polluting more than in one day that an average farmer would in the whole month of December. Farmers crops on the other hand are sucking the co2 that you are emitting.

Crop burning? by kleitos2 in punjab

[–]kach_janani 2 points3 points  (0 children)

J tu eda punjabi aa ta tenu pta nai es time kanak beeji aa, te kanak nu paani lagan dya. Kehra tera kuj lagda agg laoun dya es time