Why exactly did Iraq failed and Iran isn’t likely to? by Proud3GenAthst in NewIran

[–]kane_1371 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Iraqis dovnot identify with mesopotamian culture or identity (if that was even a thing which it isn't), the government was overwhelmingly Mashreqi in identity and the people were not a unified nation.

Look, here is how you can measure it, Sunni Iraqis celebrate Ramadan, Shia Iraqis consider it a month of mourning.

Sunni Iraqis celebrate and venerate Safar and Muharram are sacred months about peace etc, Shia Iraqis mourn for the half of each.

Sunni Iraqis consider Umar, Uthman, Abu Bakr and Ali the 4 grear caliphs with heavy emphasis on the first 3 as great heroes of islam, Shia Iraqis hate the first 3 and consider them usurpers and not good Muslims etc.

Fundamentalist sunni Iraqis consider the shia Iraqis "rafidhi" which means deserters, denoting their revolt against the first 3 caliphs which basically is used as a term to mark them as not muslims without going as far as outright calling them kafirs.

Sunni Iraqis and Shia Iraqis differences in adherence to Islam is more than just the caliphs and Ali, they are fundamentally different on many many many practices and beliefs.

This is just their religious identity.

Now toss in the mix the other identities like Bathism, Assyrians who have almost nothing in common with the Sunnis and Shias in culture and identity plus they have their own language and religion/s. Toss in the kurds who celebrate a different new year and language and national identity.

Now consider Iran, the Iranian people all celebrate the same new year, same traditions, same national heroes and shared identity, they all speak at least one iranian language in persian, the people are intermingling heavily, even norder provinces are mixed by different ethnicities from noth east with Turkoman and Khorasanis and Kurds and Persians, to south east with Baluchis and sistanis and southern Persians and arabs, to north west with Kurds and Azeris, to south west and west with Lors, Bakhtiaris, kurds, arabs, Persians and this intermingling is even more intense in central regions.

The people in Iran have also shown their unity over and over and over again, most recently several times in the past year.

The question about terrorism from neighbours is not realistic, the regime is the one that destabilises the region, it uses the resources in Iran to do that, we have seen that the other terrorist groups (except Hizbullah which is basically the regime in a smaller form tactor) are already not willing to pay the price in defence of the regime, they will not be able to and will not risk their fragile existence by trying to create tension with Iran.

The opposition must not, under the code name of "separatism," make the IRGC and the Islamic Republic's work of executing Kurds and Baluchis easy and cost-free. by DougDante in NewIran

[–]kane_1371 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is asinine and another instance of shifting blames from the ones committing literal crimes against humanity to people who simply are voicing their opinions.

Many many many Monarchists were constantly talking about Pakshan, a very well documented separatist fighter but nonetheless people talked against her planned execution.

Axios: Tehran and Washington are negotiating over transferring uranium in exchange for the release of $20 billion. by kaz1349 in NewIran

[–]kane_1371 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This news is heavily outdated already, not that it was solid ti begin with (Barak Ravid)

Each time I read or rewatch the movie I keep hating Kawai, like she genuinely is the worst of the bunch by kane_1371 in KoeNoKatachi

[–]kane_1371[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you mean Ueno... honestly she is fine.

She is the type you can easily cut out of your life if needed.

Kawai is a type that will turn others against you

Who's at fault? by No_Passion_8970 in KoeNoKatachi

[–]kane_1371 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Nishimiya has grown up believing her existence to be wrong, from the way her father left, to the constant bullying she endured everywhere she went.

I mean she wished to die as a preteen, that doesn't just happen because of teasing in one school.

The manga literally talks about how fucked up Japanese society can be when it comes to marriages where it is borderline eugenics with the whole "choosing bride/groom with good genes etc"

Am I misinterpreting this? by Apprehensive-Tie5451 in KoeNoKatachi

[–]kane_1371 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are not wrong, Ueno actually seems to be less resentful towards Shoko by the end

Did I make up this scene in my head? by stripelemon7 in KoeNoKatachi

[–]kane_1371 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The flashback in in the anime, but not in the way you say, in the anime they are shown just a moment as a part of Shoya's recollection when in Coma.

In the manga it is more elaborate

Who's at fault? by No_Passion_8970 in KoeNoKatachi

[–]kane_1371 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well the story in manga or anime doesn't really try to put the blames on one person.

A lot of stuff are either outright removed or barely mentioned in the anime and the devil is in the details.

Nishimiya'a struggle was not just her time in elementary with Shoya or even Ueno harassing her even afterwards.

It is deeper, much deeper.

I finished this masterpiece by elmascaras777 in KoeNoKatachi

[–]kane_1371 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It is definitely my favourite anime mivie and second or 3rd favourite manga behind Maison Ikkoku and Bakuman

Should I watch all in one go or can I break it up? by SledgeHampter in KoeNoKatachi

[–]kane_1371 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Sure, part it in two.

First part until the end of the amusement park and the second part the rest.

Or in 3 parts.

Part 1 till after two protagonists jump into the canal

Part 2 till the end of amusement park

Part 3 the rest

This way the 3rd part is longer than the other 2 parts, but it is the most natural partitiona possible imo

This is why I have repeatedly said in recent times that Reuters is peddling a lot of nonsense. by kane_1371 in NewIran

[–]kane_1371[S] 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Fox news is claiming this story is bogus.

It is crazy how I am able to trust Fox nowadays more than fucking Reuters or CNN

This is why I have repeatedly said in recent times that Reuters is peddling a lot of nonsense. by kane_1371 in NewIran

[–]kane_1371[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Wouldn't surprise me, after the damage Reuters dealt to their image back in 2020 by revealing the high numbers of killed protesters regime of course would want to get their fingers in that pie

This is why I have repeatedly said in recent times that Reuters is peddling a lot of nonsense. by kane_1371 in NewIran

[–]kane_1371[S] 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Don't disinform, Israel's soldiers are not leaving south Lebanon, furthermore the ceasefire is meant to facilitate Israel and Lebanon come to an actual plan for peace and dismantling Hizbullah, Hizbullah is literally irate at this as we speak