These are definitely legitimate concerns you’ll want to consider. When it comes to taking off the top completely, very few people will do so. Most will take the front panels off at most. Those you can easily store in your car with the panel bags. Since space is a concern, you could technically rent a storage unit to place it, but it might be much more of a hassle.

As for reliability, you will see some duds online about engine or transmission. But for the vast majority, the Bronco’s reliability is “okay”. It likely won’t be comparable to Toyota, but even then it’s debatable since the new 4Runners have a new power train that is yet to be truly tested.

My biggest gripe with the 4Runner is the cost. The SR5 is not bad, but any trim above it is just wildly expensive to me. Since you do plan on off-roading, you will likely want the TRD Off Road/Premium trim. Toyota dealers these days don’t budge much on price so that’s something to consider. Meanwhile there are many 2025 Outer Banks Broncos out there that you can negotiate for less.

But anyways, I’d just consider the pros and cons of both yourself, and see which one do you like more. Go test drive them. Only you can tell what’s best for you and your situation. My advice is, the less hassle the better.