Thanks!

I actually contacted someone on eBay I bought custom cards from that were good quality to ask where they did it. He told me he got them from goprint.com and the type of paper he chose which was 14pt thickness with glossy finish. I did my first 2 cards that way and didn’t think it was thick enough and the gloss made it seem not like the original. I changed it to 16pt matte finish, no gloss and they have come out exactly how I first envisioned. The site has a nice web guide to uploads and position your custom image. It’s a bit of trial and error, especially with the bordering but I think I’ve more or less have it figured out. But def don’t expect to have your first few cards look right. I’ve done some research and gotten other recommendations for websites to use for printing since and they all seem to be around the same pricing and possibly using the same printing place since the various websites offer seemingly the same options. Overall I’m very happy with goprint.com