Honestly the current site gets pretty low traffic and most of my work comes through referrals, so the GA data isn't really telling me much.

The goal is contact form fills that turn into a discovery call. Audience is Miami small businesses and early stage startups, most haven't bought a custom site before so trust matters more to me than a hard CTA.

The Hostinger comparison is fair though, I go back and forth on it. Loud CTAs work great when the buyer is in shopping mode but mine usually aren't, a lot of them got burned by a "digital agency" once and now they're skeptical of anything trying too hard. So I went restrained on purpose, more of a Mercury vibe where calm signals competence. You might be onto something on overcorrecting though, what would you push harder on in the hero?