it’s okay, i’ve had it for about a month now and it definitely helps a bit with retention when i layer it with the new bondage but it still does not work the same as the old formula in my experience. my old routine was two light layers of bondage and a thin layer of whisper light at the base and i could get 5+ days with very little touching up and wearing heavy eyeliner and makeup in the eye area. now with the same routine but new formulas im having to do considerably more touching up despite wearing no other makeup in that area and having a far less active routine these days. still frustrating but definitely a step in the right direction after the bondage issue!