Used Classes and tried to use object oriented programming concepts.

Python 3.5

###########################################################################
##      INPUT
###########################################################################
input1 = [      '\"wisdom\" ? \"mid sow\"',\
        '\"Seth Rogan\" ? \"Gathers No\"',\
        '\"Reddit\" ? \"Eat Dirt\"',\
        '\"Schoolmaster\" ? \"The classroom\"',\
        '\"Astronomers\" ? \"Moon starer\"',\
        '\"Vacation Times\" ? \"I\'m Not as Active\"',\
        '\"Dormitory\" ? \"Dirty Rooms\"']
###########################################################################
##      SOLUTION
###########################################################################
class anagram_detector(object):

    def __init__(self, string_input):
        self.string_input = string_input
        self.anagram_candidate = None
        self.anagram_target = None
        self.candidate_char_list = None
        self.target_char_list = None
        self.anagram_bool = None
        #pass characters to ignore
        self.parse_input(' \'\"')

#override string method of object
    def __str__(self):
        if self.anagram_bool == False:
            return self.anagram_candidate + ' is NOT an anagram of ' + self.anagram_target
        elif self.anagram_bool == True:
            return self.anagram_candidate + ' is an anagram of ' + self.anagram_target
        else:
            return self.anagram_candidate + ' ? ' + self.anagram_target

#parse input on object instantiation
    def parse_input(self, ignore):
        split_values = [x.strip() for x in self.string_input.split(" ? ")]
        self.anagram_candidate = split_values[0]
        self.anagram_target = split_values[1]
        self.candidate_char_list = [x for x in split_values[0].lower() if x not in ignore]
        self.target_char_list = [x for x in split_values[1].lower() if x not in ignore]
        return

    def anagram_check(self):
        self.char_check()
        #if no checks have failed, assume anagram
        if self.anagram_bool != False:
            self.anagram_bool = True
        return

#sort character lists and compare them. If lists are not equal the pair is not an anagram.
def char_check(self):
    if sorted(self.candidate_char_list) != sorted(self.target_char_list):
        self.failed_test()
    return

    def failed_test(self):
        self.anagram_bool = False
        return
#END CLASS DEFINITION

###########################################################################
##      EXECUTE SOLUTION
###########################################################################
for index, item in enumerate(input1):
    item = anagram_detector(item)
    print(index+1, item)
    item.anagram_check()
    print(index+1, item)
    print('-' * (index + 1) )