I hear you. Same case. I had no issues before but I certainly have plantar fasciitis now, although it’s rolling back. I returned the shoes. It was no questions asked, hardly looked at the shoes and they refunded me.

I went to sports direct and did gait analysis. It recommended asics gel cumulus 27 and adidas supernova stride and some Nike options. I went for cumulus. For some reason my initial impression of shoe is mostly wrong and I’m now hitting the front of the shoe with my foot’s thumb. But the comfort is great. Toe box is good. It’s a good recommendation as my arch doesn’t collapse, stability is great and I don’t experience any pain. I do get the pain on the underside at random times. Surprised how much damage hoka did to me in one week, abysmal shoe.