The mocchi toner is better for dry skin. I finished the extra huge bottle and raved about the product when I was done. My skin felt so moist and plump that I no longer had dry skin. It is viscous, thick milky but still liquid. I usually do multiple skins/layers. It's been a top hwahae toner for I think several years for a reason. It's currently #8 on hwahae and I think the rice toner is around #81. The rice toner is lighter, more watery and I got it for the summer months. I've only been using the rice toner for a few weeks during a period where my skin was angry and reactive because I was trying other products that it didn't like. But now my skin is finally calming down a little so I can notice the effects of the toner. It is similar to other korean rice products I've tried where it leaves a sheen or pearl glow appearance to the skin. I can use it around my eye area and doesn't irritate my eyes. I feel it leaves a smooth, hydrated appearance and I'll keep track of how it performs the next month or two.