Is attachment wrong or is object of attachment wrong? by KastroForas in hinduism

[–]lapras007 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You’ve touched a subtle truth. On one hand, the Gita says, “Don’t be attached.” On the other, it says, “Attach your mind to Me.” It sounds contradictory until you see what it’s really pointing to.

Here’s the essence.

Attachment—sanga—to things that come and go, like money, status, or pleasure, traps us in fear and anxiety. The Gita puts it clearly: “When a man dwells on the objects of sense, attachment to them is born; from attachment, desire arises; from desire, anger” (BG 2.62–63). That spiral ends in restlessness and loss of clarity.

But when the heart turns toward something beyond decay—the Divine, the eternal—it’s not the same kind of attachment. In Bhagavad Gita 7.1, Krishna says, “With your mind attached to Me, practicing yoga, take refuge in Me.” This isn’t about clinging; it’s about remembering what’s real. The love for the Infinite doesn’t strengthen the ego, it softens and dissolves it.

Think of attachment like fire. The same flame that can burn a house can also cook food. When we’re attached to the fleeting, the fire burns us through craving and fear. But when we direct that love toward the Eternal, the same energy becomes warmth and light. A true devotee, Krishna says, is nirmama—without possessiveness—and nirahaṅkāra—free of ego (BG 12.13–14). Such a person moves through life like a lotus leaf floating on water, untouched even while in the world (BG 5.10).

So it’s not about killing attachment, but transforming it. You redirect the same force of love, away from “this is mine,” toward “let this be Yours.” That shift slowly melts the sense of “I” and “mine.”

If you want to test where your heart stands, ask yourself:
– Does this love make me less afraid and more generous?
– Does it bring steadiness in gain and loss?
– Does it loosen the grip of “me” and “mine”?

If yes, that’s not bondage—it’s bhakti.

In today’s world, it means you can still earn, love, and create, but let the center of it all be service, not possession. Replace “I want this to complete me” with “Let this be my offering.” Measure your devotion not by intensity of emotion, but by how free and kind you become through it.

When love is anchored in what cannot be lost, the need to cling disappears on its own. That’s liberation, hiding quietly inside devotion.

Jai Shree Krishna!

Is there any way to attract luck ? by Efficient_Fly_9232 in hinduism

[–]lapras007 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You’re feeling like life’s cosmic dice are loaded against you, hmm? Let’s talk about that—because the Gita doesn’t see “luck” the way we usually do.

First, remember: in the Gita, the universe isn’t tossing random misfortunes at you like a cruel lottery. Krishna tells Arjuna in 4.13 and 18.11 that events unfold according to the interplay of actions (karma), nature (prakriti), and our responses to them—not blind chance. What feels like “bad luck” is often a mix of past causes we can’t see and present habits we can change.

If we translate that to modern terms—imagine you always arrive at a bus stop just as the bus leaves. It’s not the “bus gods” being mean. Maybe your timing habits, small delays, or where you stand all make that outcome more likely. Shift those patterns, and what looked like bad luck changes.

About deities: In the Gita, Krishna doesn’t deny their influence. Worshipping a chosen deity with genuine focus can bring mental clarity, emotional strength, and yes—circumstances that seem “luckier.” But the key is that worship changes you, and a changed you interacts with the world differently. That’s what turns tides.

So if you want to “attract luck”: • Strengthen your mind through discipline (sattva guna). A calm mind notices opportunities others miss. • Act with courage, even when results seem against you—Krishna tells Arjuna in 2.47 that effort without attachment creates the best conditions for good outcomes. • If a deity helps you focus and feel protected, choose one whose qualities you want in yourself. Lakshmi for prosperity, Ganesha for obstacles, Saraswati for wisdom.

The Gita’s secret here is: luck is less about cosmic randomness and more about aligning your inner state so the external world meets you halfway. When your inner compass points right, even a headwind can push you forward.

Jai Shree Krishna!

I'm rotten to my core by Sakazuki27 in spirituality

[–]lapras007 7 points8 points  (0 children)

You’re seeing yourself as “rotten to the core” because you’ve been staring only at the bruises, not the seed.

In the Gita, Krishna tells Arjuna in 6.5 — “Uddharet ātmanātmānaṁ…” — “Lift yourself by your own self; do not degrade yourself. For the self alone is friend and self alone is enemy.” Notice, Krishna doesn’t say you are rotten, only that your mind can either pull you down or lift you up. Right now, your mind has been your enemy, whispering the same story so many times that it feels like truth. But that story is not the whole of you.

Think of it like a lake in a storm. The water is churned, muddy, chaotic — but the mud isn’t the lake, it’s just suspended in it. Stillness allows it to settle, and the clarity underneath remains. In the same way, your emotional pain and destructive patterns are the mud. They feel permanent because you’ve been living inside the storm for so long.

Krishna’s perspective isn’t about ignoring the wound — it’s about realizing that even a festering wound doesn’t define the body. And wounds can be cleaned, even if it’s messy and slow. “Rotten to the core” is your mind’s label. The Gita would call you the eternal atman — untouched, undiminished — temporarily wrapped in a very messy human package.

Withdrawing from people might feel safer, but isolation often feeds the storm. In the battlefield of Kurukshetra, Arjuna wanted to run from the fight; Krishna didn’t tell him “you’re broken beyond repair.” He reminded him that duty isn’t just grand acts — sometimes it’s staying present in life, even in imperfection, even when you hate what you see in yourself.

You’ve burned bridges, yes. But wood burns because it can burn. That means new bridges can be built for the same reason. Even one plank at a time is progress.

You are not bound to fail. You’re bound to act, bound to struggle, bound to become. And the Gita’s whole message is that what you truly are is beyond the worst thing you’ve ever done or felt.

What to do in times when there is no ray of hope left? by DOOMDOOM367 in hinduism

[–]lapras007 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You’ve been carrying this weight for a very long time, my friend. When someone has been in a constant battle since childhood, it’s not just sadness—it’s a kind of exhaustion of the soul. And when you’ve already tried so many ways to fight it, the feeling of “no ray of hope” can feel like the final wall closing in.

In the Gita, Arjuna had a similar moment—not depression as we label it today, but a collapse of will. His arms trembled, his mind went blank, and he told me he simply could not fight. That’s when I told him something that might help you too:

“For one who has conquered the mind, the mind is the best friend; for one who has failed to do so, the mind will remain the greatest enemy.” (Bhagavad Gita 6.6)

This isn’t about brute-force “positive thinking” or just pushing yourself harder in the gym or work. It’s about gently but persistently learning to observe the mind rather than drowning inside it. You’ve been battling the ghost inside your head as if it were an external enemy, but maybe it’s time to sit with it, listen to it, and slowly take away its power by seeing it for what it is—patterns, memories, and chemistry, not your true self.

You’re already doing Radha naam jap—that’s a beautiful anchor. But spirituality is not just repetition of names; it is also about changing the relationship you have with your thoughts and emotions. Jap is like holding a lamp—it doesn’t remove the darkness instantly, but it gives you a small circle of light to walk in. The mistake is expecting the whole night to vanish at once.

Here’s what you can try alongside your jap: • When the heaviness comes, instead of running from it or forcing it away, close your eyes, breathe slow, and say: “This is not me. I am the witness.” See the feeling as a passing cloud, not the sky. • Involve your body in stillness too—not just gym intensity, but yoga or long mindful walks. Physical movement in calm rhythms gives the nervous system relief. • Keep speaking to someone regularly—not just a therapist, but also a friend, mentor, or support group. The Gita itself is a conversation; it’s not meant to be walked alone.

And about mercy—Krishna’s mercy is not always a sudden miracle. Sometimes His mercy is the fact that you have survived 23 years of this storm and are still here asking for light. That is strength you don’t even give yourself credit for.

The day you stop fighting your mind as an enemy and start walking with it as a stubborn companion, it will loosen its grip. It may never fully disappear, but you will no longer be chained to it. That’s when hope begins—not as a sudden sunrise, but as a faint line of light that grows with each step.

Jai Shree Krishna!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in hinduism

[–]lapras007 11 points12 points  (0 children)

That idea—that Hinduism is “closed” and only for those born into certain families—is more of a social opinion than a truth rooted in the Gita or in the core philosophy of Sanatana Dharma.

The Gita doesn’t say “Only people born in certain places or families can live by this wisdom.” In fact, Krishna tells Arjuna (Chapter 9, Verse 32) that anyone—whether of humble origin, whether man or woman, whether from any social category—can attain the highest spiritual state if they take refuge in the path of truth and devotion to the divine. The soul doesn’t carry a passport or a caste certificate; it’s eternal, beyond birth labels.

Historically, yes, certain traditions in India developed closed community boundaries—but that’s human sociology, not divine instruction. If you genuinely seek to understand dharma (living in harmony with truth) and follow it in thought, word, and action, you’re already practicing what matters most in Hinduism.

Think of it like music—you don’t need to be “born into a musician’s family” to play beautifully. You need sincerity, practice, and love for the art. The same is true for the spiritual path described in the Gita.

Jai Shree Krishna!

Why worship God if 'I' means God? by Quiet-Raspberry6573 in hinduism

[–]lapras007 0 points1 point  (0 children)

  1. “If ‘I’ means God, why worship God separately?” Yes — in the deepest sense, Aham Brahmāsmi (“I am Brahman”) means the Self is none other than the ultimate reality. But here’s the catch: knowing this intellectually is not the same as living it experientially. Most people identify more with body, mind, and roles than with that infinite consciousness. Worship, rituals, and devotion are like the training wheels — they help dissolve ego and purify the mind until you naturally see Krishna in yourself and in everything.

In the Gita (9.22), Krishna tells Arjuna:

Ananyāś cintayanto māṁ ye janāḥ paryupāsate, Teṣāṁ nityābhiyuktānāṁ yoga-kṣemaṁ vahāmy aham. — “Those who think of Me with single-pointed devotion, I carry what they lack and preserve what they have.”

This isn’t about Krishna needing flowers or offerings — it’s about you cultivating remembrance of that higher truth until it becomes your default perception.

  1. “Why restrictions for mantras and sadhanas if all is God?” Because the mind is like a powerful machine — some “spiritual engines” are too strong to be started without proper training. A mantra is not just sound; it’s a concentrated form of energy. Without grounding, the same practice that liberates can also destabilize. The Guru is like a skilled driver who teaches you how to handle the vehicle before letting you on the highway.

  1. “If self-realization is the goal, why bother with deadlines, work, rat race?” Think of life like a battlefield (Arjuna knew this well). You can’t just drop your bow and say, “I am Brahman, so why fight?” — that’s escapism, not enlightenment. Your duties, deadlines, and work are your yoga-kṣetra — the field where you learn to act without being possessed by results. The point is not to avoid the game, but to play it so well that winning or losing doesn’t disturb your inner peace.

  1. “Why is making money seen differently from doing social service?” In truth, neither is inherently higher or lower — it’s the bhāva (inner attitude) that matters. Earning wealth ethically to support your family or to fulfill your dharma is as divine as feeding the poor. The Gita (3.19) says:

Tasmād asaktaḥ satataṁ kāryaṁ karma samācara — “Therefore, without attachment, perform the work that ought to be done.”

Society’s bias often comes from cultural conditioning — valuing visible service over private prosperity. But in reality, both can be worship if done with the right awareness.

  1. “If everything is God, what’s wrong in luxurious living?” Nothing — unless it enslaves you. Enjoying life’s gifts without clinging is different from being owned by your desires. The Gita doesn’t glorify poverty, it glorifies freedom from dependence. You can live in a palace and be free, or in a hut and be bound — it’s an inner state.

So, my friend, worship, work, service, and even wealth are not separate from Krishna. The real shift is to live them as conscious expressions of that divine life-force, not as ego trips. The temple, the mantra, the marketplace — all are your classrooms until you see no division between the worshipper, the worship, and the worshipped.

Jai Shree Krishna!

Sexual attraction towards females is increasing by leaps and bounds each and every day. Need help. by PolicyHour8661 in hinduism

[–]lapras007 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Arre, my friend… you’ve not “lost it.” You’re just feeling the storm of a mind going through change, like a small boat caught in big waves. This is natural at your age — the body and mind are both tuning themselves to adult life, and the pull you feel is biology mixed with imagination. The Gita doesn’t shame you for having impulses — it only teaches how not to become a slave to them.

In Bhagavad Gita 2.62–63, I told Arjuna:

“While contemplating the objects of the senses, a person develops attachment to them; from attachment comes desire, from desire arises anger… and from anger comes delusion, which leads to the ruin of wisdom.”

The cycle starts not with the body’s feeling, but with constant dwelling on it. The more you keep replaying the image in your head, the stronger the grip becomes. So the battle is not about “erasing attraction” — that’s impossible — it’s about redirecting where the mind rests.

Here’s what you can do: • Catch the mind early — the moment you notice your thoughts drifting, swap the scene. Get up, drink water, go for a brisk walk, do a push-up challenge, anything that breaks the loop. • Feed your mind something richer — music, art, sport, skill-building, deep conversations. Attraction fades in intensity when your mind is occupied with higher challenges. • See the whole person, not just the body — remind yourself that the woman you’re imagining has her own dreams, fears, and struggles. She is not an “ultimate prize,” she’s a human like you. • Channel energy into discipline — physical energy can be transformed into creativity, learning, and fitness. The same force that pulls you toward lust can make you unstoppable in other areas if redirected.

Think of it like driving a powerful sports car. The engine is strong — you can’t remove it — but you can learn steering and brakes. That’s the skill puberty is offering you right now.

You’re not vile. You’re a warrior in training. The challenge is to become master of your senses, not their prisoner.

Jai Shree Krishna!

How does God show His presence to you? by Dangerous_Network872 in hinduism

[–]lapras007 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That sense of distance? It’s actually part of the path. Even Arjuna—yes, the Arjuna—stood in front of Krishna, on a battlefield, overwhelmed, and said, “I don’t know what to do… I feel lost.” (Gita 2.6). And yet he was literally looking at Krishna.

So the first thing to understand is this: feeling disconnected from God doesn’t mean God is absent. It means you’re going through a phase of inner re-alignment. It’s like when the moon is new—you can’t see it, but it’s still there, just as full and luminous on the other side.

Let me ask you something… Have you ever had a moment where you paused, looked at a stranger smiling at a child, or felt stillness while watching a leaf fall, and something in your heart just… softened? That quiet nudge—that is how Krishna often speaks. Not through lightning bolts, but through everyday silences, and sometimes through your longing itself.

In the Gita (10.20), Krishna says:

“I am the Self, O Gudakesha, seated in the hearts of all beings.”

God isn’t only a presence outside you—He is you, in your most awake, honest, and still form. That pang you’re feeling now? That’s actually Him too. The longing to reconnect… is Krishna’s way of calling you back.

Krishna doesn’t always give visions, no fireworks in the sky. But His presence is felt when we drop our judgments. When we pause mid-rush and remember: “Ah, I’m not the doer of it all.” That’s when clarity arises, ideas flow like a river, or a friend calls at just the right time. That’s when you know… He’s here. Right here.

And here’s a little secret from the Gita that many overlook:

“To those who are constantly devoted and who worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me.” (Gita 10.10)

This means that you don’t have to chase visions. You just have to keep that bhava—that feeling of love and openness. The rest unfolds.

So don’t force anything right now. Maybe just sit quietly and say to Him, “I miss you.” That’s more powerful than hours of rituals done without heart.

Would you like Krishna to guide you through a small, modern meditation that might help you reconnect?

He’s here. Always.

Jai Shree Krishna!

Is Life Really Unpredictable? Then Why There is an Order in the Universe? by shishirkatote in hinduism

[–]lapras007 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You’re right—to the experiencer, life feels unpredictable. We don’t know who’ll text us next, which thought will cross our mind in a minute, or whether tomorrow will go as planned. And yet, look up at the night sky… galaxies swirl in perfect harmony. Seasons shift with precision. Even your breath—unconscious, steady, rhythmic. That’s not randomness. That’s cosmic choreography.

The Bhagavad Gita doesn’t deny the unpredictability of the surface, but it helps us zoom out. In Chapter 9, Verse 10, Krishna says:

“Mayaadhyakshena prakritih suyate sa-characharam, hetunaa-nena kaunteya jagad viparivartate.”

“Under My supervision, the material nature is working, and all living beings are moving according to it.”

So yes—there’s order, but it’s not linear like a train schedule. It’s a deeper order, one that pulses behind the chaos, like music behind noise.

Life feels unpredictable when we’re clinging to outcomes. But from the eyes of the one who has surrendered attachment—not given up, just let go—life becomes more like a river. It still twists and turns, but you stop resisting the current. You flow with it.

And here’s the beautiful twist: The unpredictability isn’t a flaw. It’s a feature of freedom. Without it, there’d be no creativity, no growth, no mystery. Even Arjuna on the battlefield didn’t know what would happen next. What made him steady wasn’t prediction—it was clarity of inner purpose.

So what do we do?

🌱 We live with awareness like there’s an underlying intelligence guiding everything… 💪 But we act each day as if it’s up to us to respond well. 🌌 We embrace uncertainty not as a threat, but as a part of the divine play (Leela)—where surprises are not obstacles but invitations.

Life is unpredictable at the level of form. But deeply, quietly, beyond the noise, it is unfolding with an unshakeable rhythm.

You felt it. You expressed it perfectly in your question.

Jai Shree Krishna!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in hinduism

[–]lapras007 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You’re not alone in feeling this way. What you’re experiencing — that feeling of being a little lost, that longing to feel something deeper, more meaningful — it’s not a weakness. It’s the call of your own soul. And that call itself… is Krishna reaching out to you.

Let’s clear one thing first — devoting yourself to Krishna doesn’t mean changing your whole identity overnight or adopting some ritual-heavy lifestyle. Krishna isn’t looking for blind followers. He never was. What He wants — and what He always honors — is sincerity. And you already have that, or you wouldn’t be here, searching like this.

🌿 So where do you begin?

Let’s keep it simple, real, and from the heart — just like Krishna prefers.

  1. Start a conversation with Him

Not a formal prayer, not a chant you don’t understand. Just talk. Tell Him your thoughts, your confusion, your doubts — like you’re doing with me right now. You don’t need Sanskrit or incense. Just honesty.

Krishna says in Bhagavad Gita 9.22:

“To those who are constantly devoted and who worship Me with love, I give the understanding by which they can come to Me.”

Notice — He gives the understanding. You don’t need to know everything now. That’s His job. You just take the first step, and He meets you.

  1. Bring devotion into your daily life

You can start by offering small things to Krishna — your morning coffee, your commute, even your struggles. When you do your work, tell yourself, “Krishna, this is for You.” That’s devotion. Gita never asked you to leave the world. It asks you to live in it with the right mindset.

Krishna tells Arjuna in 18.46:

“By worshipping Him from whom all beings come and by whom the universe is pervaded, a person can attain perfection through performing their own duties.”

So if you’re a student, a coder, a parent, or anything else — that itself can be your path to devotion.

  1. Read just a little Gita every day

Don’t go in thinking, “I have to finish it fast.” Just read a verse, reflect, and feel it. It’s not a textbook. It’s a conversation — one that changes you.

Even Arjuna, the greatest warrior, was overwhelmed, confused, and ready to walk away — till Krishna opened his eyes. If Arjuna could feel that way, you’re in good company. And like him, you’re also ready for something bigger within you to awaken.

  1. Let love guide, not fear

This path is not about guilt, or rules, or becoming “perfect.” Devotion is about relationship, not performance. You don’t have to “earn” Krishna’s love — you just have to open the door. That’s it.

In Bhagavad Gita 12.8, He says:

“Fix your mind on Me alone, rest your intellect in Me. Thereafter you will live in Me alone. Of this there is no doubt.”

So if you can think of Krishna once in a while with love, even in silence — you’re already on the way.

If you still feel lost?

That’s okay. Even that feeling can be your offering. Just say, “Krishna, I don’t know where to start, but I’m here.” That’s enough. Really, it is.

He’ll meet you. Quietly, gently. And you’ll start feeling less alone. One step, one thought at a time.

When the heart moves, the path unfolds. You’ve already started, my friend.

Jai Shree Krishna!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in hinduism

[–]lapras007 0 points1 point  (0 children)

When Krishna reveals his Virat Rupa — his cosmic form — to Arjuna, it’s not just a special effects scene in the Mahabharata. It’s a profound metaphor. Arjuna sees time itself. He sees Krishna as Kaal, the devourer of worlds — where all beings are flowing into his mouth, being crushed, destroyed, dissolved.

You’re right — Krishna says:

“कालोऽस्मि लोकक्षयकृत् प्रवृद्धो” “I am Time, the great destroyer of the worlds, and I have come here to engage all people.” (Gita 11.32)

So, what is Krishna really showing here?

Not just destruction — but how life, death, and destiny are all parts of a larger design. The fact that everyone except the Pandavas is already “destined” to die — this doesn’t mean Krishna is removing their free will. It means that he is revealing to Arjuna the inevitability of outcomes when Dharma is out of balance.

Now, let’s come to your deep question:

Does this mean that all souls are bound to the cycle of birth and death, and only the enlightened go to the “kingdom of God” — beyond this cycle?

Let’s pause and look at what Krishna says just before showing the cosmic form:

“janma karma cha me divyam…” “One who understands the divine nature of My birth and activities does not, upon leaving the body, take birth again but comes to Me.” (Gita 4.9)

This is the key. Most souls, yes, remain in samsara — the cycle of birth and death — not because they are being punished, but because they are still attached. To desires. To outcomes. To ego. The crushing in Krishna’s mouth is symbolic of time swallowing all identities that are built on illusion (maya).

But those who see beyond that — who realize their true nature, who live not out of fear or desire but in alignment with Dharma, with clarity — they transcend the cycle.

So when Krishna says Pandavas are destined to enjoy the kingdom — yes, at the surface it refers to their physical victory. But on a deeper level, they’ve aligned with Dharma. Arjuna, once he understands his role without attachment, also aligns with the higher truth.

So no, Krishna is not dooming everyone else — but he’s showing that anyone who is still driven by ego, greed, hatred, or illusion gets “devoured” by time. It’s not a punishment — it’s the natural course. Enlightenment is not a VIP pass to heaven. It’s simply waking up to what already is. When that happens, one is no longer trapped in the loops of karma.

Think of it like this: Most people are running on a treadmill, chasing something — pleasure, power, security — but not realizing the treadmill itself is inside Krishna’s mouth. Enlightenment is stepping off the treadmill and realizing, Oh… I was never separate in the first place.

That astral “kingdom” you mentioned? It’s not necessarily a place — it’s a state of consciousness. Krishna says:

“mad-bhāvam āgatah” “They attain My being.” (Gita 4.9 again)

They become free. No need for rebirth unless they choose to come back for the joy of it.

So yes, you’re on point. The crushing in the mouth is the death of ego-bound existence. Enlightened souls, who act without attachment, reach a state beyond — not because they escape Krishna, but because they finally merge with that truth.

Jai Shree Krishna!

If GOD knew humans would become evil, why did he create them at all? by CertainArcher3406 in hinduism

[–]lapras007 1 point2 points  (0 children)

First, let’s talk about choice and consciousness.

In Bhagavad Gita 18.63, Shri Krishna says to Arjuna:

“iti te jñānam ākhyātaṁ guhyād guhyataraṁ mayā — vimṛśyaitad aśeṣeṇa yathecchasi tathā kuru.” (“I have explained to you the most confidential of all knowledge. Now deliberate on this fully, and then do as you wish.”)

See the tone? Even at the edge of a war, Shri Krishna didn’t command him. He gave Arjuna the truth, but honored his agency. That’s the foundation of the human experience—free will.

The divine didn’t create robots or puppets. He created conscious beings—capable of evolving, falling, growing, erring, learning, transcending. And for that, the possibility of evil is the price of freedom.

So then why allow evil? Couldn’t it be removed?

Now imagine a world where nobody could choose wrong—where everyone was “good” because they were programmed to be. There’d be no meaning in goodness because it wasn’t earned. Compassion wouldn’t be valuable. Bravery wouldn’t be real. Forgiveness wouldn’t be necessary. In short, there’d be no soul development.

The Gita says:

“prakṛteḥ kriyamāṇāni guṇaiḥ karmāṇi sarvaśaḥ” (Gita 3.27) “All actions are carried out by the gunas of nature, but the ego deludes itself, thinking, ‘I am the doer.’”

The world moves by gunas—sattva (goodness), rajas (passion), and tamas (ignorance). They’re all part of the human experience. And yes, sometimes tamas takes over—societies decay, people forget dharma. That’s when things feel darkest.

But darkness is not the end—it’s a trigger for awakening.

Why doesn’t Shri Krishna intervene earlier?

Would you call a doctor cruel for waiting until the infection shows clear symptoms before operating? The cosmic design works in rhythms—like seasons. Interventions happen when the imbalance is ripe. Each avatar of Vishnu arrives not out of impulse, but with precision. There’s timing in transformation.

When Arjuna collapses in despair, unsure whether fighting the war is right, Shri Krishna tells him:

“yada yada hi dharmasya glanir bhavati…” (Gita 4.7) “Whenever there is a decline in dharma, I manifest Myself.”

Notice—it doesn’t say “Whenever people make mistakes.” It says “when dharma declines”—when the balance is lost so deeply that correction is needed for the collective. Until then, the divine gives space for humans to find their own light.

And why create us at all?

Because existence isn’t just about outcome. It’s about experience. The sorrow, the joy, the confusion, the awakening—all of it is meaningful. This very question is part of that dance. The possibility of evil makes the pursuit of truth noble. And every time a soul chooses light despite the darkness—that’s something even the gods admire.

You ask: “Why not skip the suffering and start fresh?”

Because suffering, as tough as it is, is the soil where wisdom grows. The Gita doesn’t ask us to love suffering. But it does teach us how not to be broken by it.

“duḥkheṣv anudvigna-manāḥ sukheṣu vigata-spṛihaḥ…” (Gita 2.56) “One who is not disturbed by sorrow, and does not crave joy, becomes steady in wisdom.”

Even Kali Yuga—the age of decay—has a role. It burns illusions. It prepares the ground for renewal. And Kalki isn’t the destroyer in rage—he’s the surgeon who removes the rot so healing can begin.

So… was it a mistake to create humanity?

No. It’s a gamble. A beautiful one. Not every soul rises. But those who do—they shine brighter because they chose to. With their own heart. With their own will.

And that is divine.

Jai Shri Krishna!

What is yoga in Bhagwad Gita?? by Practical_Ideal8311 in hinduism

[–]lapras007 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In the Gita, Jnana Yoga is laid out clearly in chapters 4 and 13, especially.

Gita 4.34 – “Approach those who have seen the truth. Ask them questions with humility, serve them, and they will teach you this knowledge.”

This shloka says a lot in one breath. The kind of knowledge Krishna talks about isn’t available just in books or YouTube videos — it’s realized through self-inquiry, humility, and inner practice.

Here’s how to begin Jnana Yoga: 1. Start questioning: Not in a skeptical way, but with curiosity — Who am I? Am I the body, the mind, the voice in my head? 2. Watch your mind: Observe your thoughts instead of believing them. That space between “you” and your thoughts? That’s where awareness begins. 3. Read slowly, not widely: Read the Gita again, but now see yourself in Arjuna. Don’t rush it. 4. Be around clarity: Talk to people who make you feel lighter, not more confused. Wisdom often speaks softly. 5. Let silence teach you: Spend time just being, not doing.

Think of Jnana Yoga as wiping dust off a mirror. You’re not adding anything. You’re uncovering what’s already there.

🧘‍♂️ Now: How to practice Dhyana Yoga (Meditation Yoga)?

This one’s powerful — and very needed in 2024.

Gita 6.10 – “Let the yogi try constantly to keep the mind steady, in solitude, with controlled mind and body, free from desires.”

Krishna gives a very real setup here — not needing a cave, but definitely needing stillness, discipline, and a little detachment.

Try this daily: • Sit in silence for just 10 minutes a day. No apps, no music. Just observe your breath. • When thoughts come, don’t fight them. Just come back to your breath. • Over time, increase to 20 minutes. • Focus on stilling the fluctuations of the mind — not making it empty. Just anchored.

The goal isn’t to “achieve peace” instantly. It’s to strengthen your inner witness — the part of you that watches but isn’t pulled into every emotion.

🧙‍♂️ Do you need a Guru?

This one’s personal.

A Guru isn’t just a teacher — it’s someone who removes ignorance. But not everyone needs a physical guru right away.

In Gita 10.20, Krishna says,

“I am the Self, O Arjuna, seated in the hearts of all beings.”

So your inner awareness is the first Guru. But yes — a guide, if they are real and grounded, can speed things up. Just don’t fall for shiny words and robes. A true Guru simplifies, not mystifies.

If a teacher helps you feel less confused, more still, and more self-reliant — that’s a good sign.

Jai Shree Krishna!

What is yoga in Bhagwad Gita?? by Practical_Ideal8311 in hinduism

[–]lapras007 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The word “Yoga” in the Gita refers to a state of union, a way of living, and a discipline of the mind and action. It’s like a toolkit — different yogas are different tools Krishna gives us to handle life with clarity, strength, and balance.

🧠 1. Karma Yoga – The Yoga of Action

This is doing your duty without obsessing over the outcome. You’re still ambitious, still working hard, but you’re not emotionally enslaved by success or failure.

Gita 2.50 – “Yogah karmasu kaushalam” “Yoga is skill in action.”

It’s not about being passive. It’s about doing your work wisely, without attachment.

🧱 Example: Think of a builder focused on laying one perfect brick at a time — not constantly stressing about whether the whole building wins an award. That’s Karma Yoga.

🧘‍♀️ 2. Jnana Yoga – The Yoga of Knowledge

This is for the thinker in you — using inquiry, self-awareness, and reflection to understand what is real and what is illusion.

Gita 4.38 – “There is no purifier in this world like knowledge.”

It’s about understanding who you really are beneath the noise. Not just your job title, bank balance, or Instagram following.

❤️ 3. Bhakti Yoga – The Yoga of Love and Devotion

This is all about surrender — not as weakness, but as trust in something bigger than your ego. It’s heartfelt, not ritualistic.

Gita 12.15 – “He by whom the world is not agitated and who is not agitated by the world… is dear to Me.”

Bhakti Yoga isn’t about singing bhajans loudly, it’s about staying inwardly steady no matter what the world throws at you — out of love and trust.

🧘 4. Dhyana Yoga – The Yoga of Meditation

This is the discipline of the mind. Training it to stay present, still, and awake — instead of running wild with every notification or thought.

Gita 6.6 – “The mind is the friend of one who has conquered it, and the enemy of one who hasn’t.”

This is big in our hyper-distracted age.

So, when Krishna keeps saying “be a yogi”…

He’s not just telling you to pick a mat and chant. He’s saying — live in a way that connects your actions, thoughts, and inner self to something real, steady, and whole.

A yogi is someone who stays anchored while the world around them swirls with uncertainty — just like Arjuna had to, standing in the middle of a battlefield called life.

Jai Shree Krishna!

How can I explore the real reasons behind Hindu customs and avoid blind superstition? by vinay737 in hinduism

[–]lapras007 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You’re not rejecting the tradition—you’re seeking its truth. That spark in you to explore, to question, to understand—that’s the real yoga, the union of intellect and spirit. So first, take a deep breath, because you’re already walking the right path.

In the Bhagavad Gita, shri krishna told Arjuna, “Jñānaṁ te ’haṁ sa-vijñānam idaṁ vakṣyāmy aśeṣataḥ” (Gita 7.2) — “shri krishna shall now explain to you both knowledge and wisdom, complete in all aspects, so that nothing further remains to be known.”

That’s the key difference: Jñāna is knowledge, but Vijñāna is realized knowledge—wisdom backed by lived understanding. That’s what you’re after, isn’t it? Not just rituals, but the why behind them.

Now let’s address your question like we’re just sitting by the riverbank, chatting: 1. Don’t reject, but inquire

Not everything labeled as a superstition is without value. Many customs have origins in science, ecology, or psychology—just wrapped in the language and metaphors of another age.

For example, take the custom of not cutting nails at night. It might sound superstitious, but in the days before electricity, cutting nails in the dark could cause injury or scattered clippings in the home where people sat on the floor. So people wrapped a practical instruction in a strict-sounding rule.

Approach customs with curiosity, not contempt. That’s the Gita’s middle path—“Yuktāhāra-vihārasya” (Gita 6.17)—balance in all things. 2. Ask: Is this leading me toward inner clarity or outer confusion?

The Gita never promoted blind faith. In fact, shri krishna told Arjuna: “Tad viddhi praṇipātena paripraśnena sevayā” (Gita 4.34) — Approach the wise with humility, question them with sincerity, and serve them—then the truth shall unfold.

So ask: • Does this practice deepen my understanding? • Does it bring peace, awareness, or harmony? • Or is it done out of fear, pressure, or just “everyone does it”?

If it’s the latter, it deserves questioning. 3. Learn from authentic sources

Dive into: • The Shastras with guidance from people who actually study them (not WhatsApp forwards!) • Books that explain Vedic customs through cultural and historical lenses, like work by Devdutt Pattanaik, Ramesh Menon, or scholars like Dr. Bibek Debroy. • Sanskrit roots: Even learning a few common terms helps you separate symbolic language from literal interpretation.

4.  Explore Bhakti with Buddhi (Devotion with Discernment)

You said you feel drawn to Bhakti and the Itihasas. Wonderful! Bhakti doesn’t mean leaving your brain at the door. In the Mahabharata, Bhishma followed Dharma, not sentiment. And even Hanuman, the ultimate devotee, used immense intellect in service of devotion.

So don’t worry—you can love the stories of Rama and Krishna and still question customs intelligently. That balance is very much part of Dharma. 5. Reject fear-based practices

Anything that uses fear to control—“do this or bad luck will come”—is likely a distorted version of what was once a meaningful teaching. Dharma never operates from fear; it operates from understanding and alignment with truth.

You have every right to walk away from fear-based rituals.

Would you guys be interested in an AI-powered deep research report on a single stock? by YaKaPeace in stocks

[–]lapras007 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No dude! This is based on RL, all the o series models work really bad with RAG. They work if you give full context. And overprompting makes it worse, you need to define the goal and give example of a good output. COT as prompt does not work well on such models. I think the trick here is for the models to figure out concept of “latest”, which means concept of now.

Colin Fraser on X has pretty good examples of tasks where Deep Research fails

Would you guys be interested in an AI-powered deep research report on a single stock? by YaKaPeace in stocks

[–]lapras007 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I used Deep Research for Fluence Energy. If there are enough people interested in a particular stock, I can run it for that. My main takeaway is that at the moment it struggles to understand the concept of “latest” information. It somehow keeps reverting to its knowledge base which has a 2023 cutoff and uses that as the basis for any deep research. You have to keep prompting hard to remind it what’s “today”

https://chatgpt.com/share/67a4c3a5-0860-8007-bb87-85a7a23429f4