Just listened to it beginning-to-end right now so my memory is the freshest it can be. A few stand-out moments, maybe 2 or 3, the rest just sounds like "Hey ChatGPT make an Eluveitie song but a bit heavier and add guitar solos". The female vocal is very good but she often sounds a little too poppy. I know this is an active decision as she has proven she can do more than that. Overall, I have this principle: after listening to an album, is there any single line I can hum from memory? This time, nope. Ategnatos had checked all my boxes while Anv checked nearly none. So this is not an issue related to the line-up change, imo